National Forum



Most Popular Posts in the last 24hrs

Click on the subject to bring you to the county where the message was originally posted 
(this page is sorted with the most popular posts at the top)


Roscommon GAA thread - 3 Like(s)

Replying To 3rdmidfielder:  ""County board spending is well monitored ". 325k is a crazy money to spend on managing amateur sports teams. It's not just Roscommon either btw. It's obvious where the bulk of that money went. Value for money?"
I posted up more than the well monitored bit but the admin/mods edited my post. It was explaining why.

The_analyser (National) - 20/12/2024 15:42:27

Football Format Changes Discussion - 1 Like(s)

Replying To omahant:  "As you stated, I also don't think 'decoupling' Prov SFCs would get approved (e.g. Ulster says NO! in particular). My AILC neither fully couples nor decouples - with no Sam guarantee, Prov match pts are kind of a halfway house. The 'alternating week' schedule though is a good one. Given a total playing calendar of about 40 weeks (say, start-Feb to mid-Nov) - I suppose to be objectively fair - the inter-county and club should allocate evenly - each get 20 weeks, maybe split into 4 windows. That would require a smaller inter-county footprint - maybe with league reduced to 4-6 games. As the league with its '4 divs of 8' is so popular - it could be left in place - a Swiss System could reduce the schedule from 7 games. Say, for scheduling only - teams are ranked 1-8 in each div - 6-game schedule, A1458 v B2367, and in each group (A or B), 'best & worst v mid 2' (i.e. A18 v A45 & B27 v B36). For 5 games, A1458 v B2367, and in each group teams 'with a seeding difference of 4', play the extra game (i.e. A1vA5, A4vA8, B2vB6 & B3vB7). For 4 games, it's just A1458 v B2367."
If the league was complete in 7 weeks: 123, break, 4, 5 and finals - the provincial championships could be played over 7 weeks and the double elimination championship over 11 weeks. A team would always have at least 1 weekend off after each championship match. Regards your Swiss System for league. Just have 4 seeded groups. All teams to play 1 team from each seeded group. After 4 rounds: Top 4 into semi-finals. Bottom 4 into relegation semi-finals. Only division winners promoted. Relegation final losers relegated. Job done. NFL complete after 6 rounds. No fuss! ;-)

legendzxix (National) - 20/12/2024 20:45:05