Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

National Forum

Some Updates On The Football Review

(Oldest Posts First) - Go To The Latest Post

Replying To brayballer:  "A fisted point needs a certain amount of skill but a hand passed point needs no skill whatsoever.Its too easy.The handpassing has become tiresome and is more like basketball now.I know its hard for a ref to count the hand passes but players handpassing over and back the park in boring and also skillless."
Why are people obsessed with every action being a skillful one.

Ban fisted points and there will be less goals scored for a fact.

Handpassing across the pitch is far better than slow 5 yard kickpasses because you're not allowed handpass it. Or even worse is ball being kicked forward for the sake of it.

otgarom (Mayo) - Posts: 60 - 20/11/2026 00:12:56    2700858

Link

Replying To otgarom:  "Why are people obsessed with every action being a skillful one.

Ban fisted points and there will be less goals scored for a fact.

Handpassing across the pitch is far better than slow 5 yard kickpasses because you're not allowed handpass it. Or even worse is ball being kicked forward for the sake of it."
Are you for real? How would banning fisted points mean less goals?
If anything it might force a player to shoot for goal as the handy handpass point would nt be allowed.
Also a kick pass is more skilfiul and would also give the opposition a better chance of intercepting.Yoir post makes no sense.

brayballer (Wicklow) - Posts: 828 - 20/11/2026 12:28:16    2700923

Link

Replying To Fionn:  "Slapping a ball into the net is the worst of the lot."
Agree 100% Fionn.Its a ridiculous score.No skill at all and sometimes its even scooped in to the net.I know we scored a good few like that but I hate them.

brayballer (Wicklow) - Posts: 828 - 20/11/2026 12:31:23    2700924

Link

How could 1-10 to 0-14 be a draw. Hurts my eyes

97Cavans (Cavan) - Posts: 459 - 20/11/2026 13:09:22    2700928

Link

Replying To brayballer:  "Are you for real? How would banning fisted points mean less goals?
If anything it might force a player to shoot for goal as the handy handpass point would nt be allowed.
Also a kick pass is more skilfiul and would also give the opposition a better chance of intercepting.Yoir post makes no sense."
Handpass points would reduce goals because forwards would no longer take on their man and go for goal as often, the nature of the game means that when a player does that they are going to get botted up. When they do it now they do it in the knowledge that if they do they have the safety net of handpassing a point if it doesn't work out, remove the safety net and forwards will just try and work enough space to kick a point rather than go past their man, esp3cially near the endline.

It's not more skillful for you to scuttle a 5 yard kickpass to man with 15 yards of space around him than to handpass it, neither are going to be intercepted but kicking it removes brilliant attacking moves from the game and makes it more posession based because again, a man isn't going to take on their man if the next pass has to be a kick unless they're sure of getting the shot off.

Also, we are the only sport in the world that is obsessed with every action being the most skillful one possible, you can't make a sport so that there is only one way to play it, that removes layers of nuance and coaching from the game.

otgarom (Mayo) - Posts: 60 - 21/11/2026 11:02:24    2701018

Link

Replying To brayballer:  "Agree 100% Fionn.Its a ridiculous score.No skill at all and sometimes its even scooped in to the net.I know we scored a good few like that but I hate them."
Do you just want to back to the dark ages of the goalie belting it out 50/50 and whoever wins it kicking high straight into the full forward line?

otgarom (Mayo) - Posts: 60 - 21/11/2026 11:04:46    2701019

Link

Replying To otgarom:  "Do you just want to back to the dark ages of the goalie belting it out 50/50 and whoever wins it kicking high straight into the full forward line?"
No I want good skilfill ball play.Do you think the handpass point is skilful?Serious question.

brayballer (Wicklow) - Posts: 828 - 21/11/2026 16:23:09    2701053

Link

Replying To brayballer:  "No I want good skilfill ball play.Do you think the handpass point is skilful?Serious question."
I absolutely agree with you. Ban the hand pass point and while they are at it ban the toe poke goal from a yard out too. Neither are skillful enough to be worthy of a score in this great game. This idea of giving a free on the 13m line straight in front of the posts is ridiculous too. Move it the 13m by all means but it must be on the sideline. Now that's worthy of being a score....

Tadhg2020 (Limerick) - Posts: 783 - 21/11/2026 16:36:29    2701061

Link

Replying To brayballer:  "No I want good skilfill ball play.Do you think the handpass point is skilful?Serious question."
4 point goal not going to trials.

Seanfan (Roscommon) - Posts: 1024 - 21/11/2026 16:46:02    2701064

Link

Replying To brayballer:  "No I want good skilfill ball play.Do you think the handpass point is skilful?Serious question."
Not everything needs to be a skill,the skill is in getting to close enough to the goal to handpass a point but the goal isn't on,remove it and people won't get that close to goal anymore.

otgarom (Mayo) - Posts: 60 - 21/11/2026 17:23:17    2701070

Link

Dilemma - Goal Value - 4 or 3 pts?

Equally legitimate arguments state:
a) why should two 2-pointers be worth more than a goal?; and b) would a 4-pointer cheapen the 1-pointer?

If sympathetic to both arguments, perhaps 3.5 is the correct value (rounded down to eliminate the decimal) - so a 'pair of goals' is neither 6 nor 8, but 7 pts.

Colm O'Rourke has argued that the 2-pointer would be better if required to be kicked from outside the 45 - the line making the distance longer from an angle.

I wouldn't mind having 2-pointers more difficult, less frequent and therefore, more special.

omahant (USA) - Posts: 3616 - 21/11/2026 17:29:58    2701073

Link

Replying To omahant:  "Dilemma - Goal Value - 4 or 3 pts?

Equally legitimate arguments state:
a) why should two 2-pointers be worth more than a goal?; and b) would a 4-pointer cheapen the 1-pointer?

If sympathetic to both arguments, perhaps 3.5 is the correct value (rounded down to eliminate the decimal) - so a 'pair of goals' is neither 6 nor 8, but 7 pts.

Colm O'Rourke has argued that the 2-pointer would be better if required to be kicked from outside the 45 - the line making the distance longer from an angle.

I wouldn't mind having 2-pointers more difficult, less frequent and therefore, more special."
The problem with making 2 pointers harder, especially if it was to be from outside the 45 is that teans would just drop deeper and mark the 2 players per team capable of kicking from there, whereas now a team has to be more pushed out defensively as a lot of teamd have 5 or 6 potential 2 point kickers meaning that goal chances can be created.

otgarom (Mayo) - Posts: 60 - 21/11/2026 18:51:36    2701085

Link

Replying To otgarom:  "The problem with making 2 pointers harder, especially if it was to be from outside the 45 is that teans would just drop deeper and mark the 2 players per team capable of kicking from there, whereas now a team has to be more pushed out defensively as a lot of teamd have 5 or 6 potential 2 point kickers meaning that goal chances can be created."
Exactly, the question isnt about the worthiness of the value of the score. The question is how will it affect how the game is played.
The 2 pointer has had a huge affect on how both teams play the game. Teams attacking seek the reward of the 2 pointer and the defending team has to set up to try and stop it thus potentially leaving space in behind. You make the 2 pointer harder and teams wont pursue them as much. Teams defending will adapt accordingly. They will drop deeper to defend the goal and make 1 pointers more difficult.
This also applies to the 4 point goal. You are more likely to set up to prevent the premium score. I think this is the reason that they aren't persisting with it. Its affect on the game would be negative ultimately

Tadhg2020 (Limerick) - Posts: 783 - 21/11/2026 20:12:26    2701096

Link

Replying To Tadhg2020:  "Exactly, the question isnt about the worthiness of the value of the score. The question is how will it affect how the game is played.
The 2 pointer has had a huge affect on how both teams play the game. Teams attacking seek the reward of the 2 pointer and the defending team has to set up to try and stop it thus potentially leaving space in behind. You make the 2 pointer harder and teams wont pursue them as much. Teams defending will adapt accordingly. They will drop deeper to defend the goal and make 1 pointers more difficult.
This also applies to the 4 point goal. You are more likely to set up to prevent the premium score. I think this is the reason that they aren't persisting with it. Its affect on the game would be negative ultimately"
100%, people don't seem to understand the knock on impact of the rules they're proposing, you need to think about how teams will set up to limit each other or not fall foul of changes and quite often the way they would set up would negatively impact the game.

otgarom (Mayo) - Posts: 60 - 21/11/2026 21:41:57    2701104

Link

Replying To Seanfan:  "4 point goal not going to trials."
Who will be the next expert committee put together by HQ is the next question.

McStay's fronted group was holding onto hope for a four pointer goal and restricted hand passes neither got much if any support.

The_analyser (Roscommon) - Posts: 4561 - 21/11/2026 21:47:33    2701106

Link

Replying To The_analyser:  "Who will be the next expert committee put together by HQ is the next question.

McStay's fronted group was holding onto hope for a four pointer goal and restricted hand passes neither got much if any support."
Didn't need a high powered (and well expensed) committee to suggest the few things going forward.
Isn't or wasn't there a rules revision group there for years to recommend tweaks to playing rules?

Anyway I'm disappointed there seems no proposal to tweak the A I series to give a bigger reward to provincial champions than the team they bet in the final , or a fairer neutral venue in the eliminator games 2B and 3.

Seanfan (Roscommon) - Posts: 1024 - 21/11/2026 22:25:32    2701110

Link

Replying To Seanfan:  "Didn't need a high powered (and well expensed) committee to suggest the few things going forward.
Isn't or wasn't there a rules revision group there for years to recommend tweaks to playing rules?

Anyway I'm disappointed there seems no proposal to tweak the A I series to give a bigger reward to provincial champions than the team they bet in the final , or a fairer neutral venue in the eliminator games 2B and 3."
Absolutely, it was a disgrace that Meath had to play 3 away games in the Championship. Cork, Mayo and Derry is a joke

RoyalStalwart24 (Meath) - Posts: 150 - 22/11/2026 00:50:01    2701117

Link

So lads. How do we feel on the new rules to be trialled for the League? Six subs, extension of 40 metre arc to endlines, and some other technical changes.

I'm personally against any changes outside of the format

RoyalStalwart24 (Meath) - Posts: 150 - 22/11/2026 01:54:45    2701120

Link

Replying To RoyalStalwart24:  "So lads. How do we feel on the new rules to be trialled for the League? Six subs, extension of 40 metre arc to endlines, and some other technical changes.

I'm personally against any changes outside of the format"
A point from the corner flag should be worth as much as a 40.5m free with a gale behind you
Six subs definitely required as much more action in games under new rules.
Sideline thing is totally silly.
Rest I'm easy with.

Seanfan (Roscommon) - Posts: 1024 - 22/11/2026 11:19:24    2701128

Link

Replying To Tadhg2020:  "I absolutely agree with you. Ban the hand pass point and while they are at it ban the toe poke goal from a yard out too. Neither are skillful enough to be worthy of a score in this great game. This idea of giving a free on the 13m line straight in front of the posts is ridiculous too. Move it the 13m by all means but it must be on the sideline. Now that's worthy of being a score...."
Frees inside 21 in front of goal should be taken off the ground also.

brayballer (Wicklow) - Posts: 828 - 22/11/2026 12:31:46    2701136

Link