Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

National Forum

Galway Hurling thread

(Oldest Posts First) - Go To The Latest Post

Replying To Conntribunesh:  "Does anyone know anything about the two McCarthaighs from sarsfields and Pierce McGurk? Called in also"
If this is true you wonder how with the performance of Sarsfield's in the club championship.

Watchthepost (Dublin) - Posts: 21 - 19/11/2026 14:58:31    2700795

Link

Replying To Watchthepost:  "If this is true you wonder how with the performance of Sarsfield's in the club championship."
Surely how well a club team does depends on how 15 or 20 players play, not 2 or 3?

Viking66 (Wexford) - Posts: 21020 - 19/11/2026 15:40:32    2700797

Link

Replying To Viking66:  "Surely how well a club team does depends on how 15 or 20 players play, not 2 or 3?"
I would put the three cooneys, morrissey and ian fox as the best hurlers in Sarsfields at the moment

Conntribunesh (Galway) - Posts: 15 - 19/11/2026 17:53:28    2700802

Link

Replying To Watchthepost:  "If this is true you wonder how with the performance of Sarsfield's in the club championship."
That makes no sense. Ahascragh had two of our best county players for years and didn't make a dent in the senior championship. A club team needs far more than 2 or 3 top players to compete for a senior title, if the supporting cast isn't at the required level.

WanPintWin (Galway) - Posts: 3184 - 19/11/2026 17:55:47    2700803

Link

Replying To Conntribunesh:  "Here is a toned-down version of the Galway hurling post. It keeps your core argument-that management is leaning too heavily on young U20s and overlooking proven club players from teams like Loughrea-while removing the personal digs at selectors, clubmates, and individual young players so it reads as constructive criticism and passes HoganStand moderation easily:

It is well past time that the Galway senior hurling management took a closer look at how the panel is being selected.

Right now, there is a clear bias towards familiar faces and recent U20 graduates:

A heavy proportion of the squad is drawn directly from management's own clubs, with Clarinbridge and Turloughmore making up ten spots between them, alongside further representation from Eyrecourt, Pearses, and Cappataggle.

Meanwhile, management has opted to bring through a wave of young U20s while overlooking seasoned hurlers who have consistently proven themselves at senior club level.

It is no surprise that lighter, less experienced players struggle to impose themselves against physical, battle-hardened outfits like Limerick, where the likes of Gearóid Hegarty, Kyle Hayes, Dan Morrissey, Cian Lynch, Tom Morrissey, Aaron Gillane, Shane O'Brien, and William O'Donoghue set the standard.

Management needs to put more stock in what is happening on the ground in the Galway senior club championship rather than relying so heavily on the underage pathway. Loughrea-the standout club side in the county over the last few years after completing three-in-a-row-only have two potential starters in the mix. Players like Jamie Ryan, arguably the top club hurler in Galway this season, have barely been given a fair look-in.

Truth be told, it is still the experienced core-Pádraic and Cathal Mannion, Daithí Burke, Conor Whelan, and Conor Cooney-carrying this side. Unless management starts integrating proven, physically ready club performers now, Galway hurling will face a steep drop-off once that generation steps away."
There isnt a hurler in the county this year that would draw water to Jamie Ryan... The closest is tiernan Killeen after that club championship display. Jamie should be given a full league campaign for the Galway hurlers this year, especially after that horrific thumb injury he received. To get back to the level he's playing at again is mind boggling.

BigBàsMan (Galway) - Posts: 315 - 19/11/2026 18:15:39    2700808

Link

Replying To BigBàsMan:  "There isnt a hurler in the county this year that would draw water to Jamie Ryan... The closest is tiernan Killeen after that club championship display. Jamie should be given a full league campaign for the Galway hurlers this year, especially after that horrific thumb injury he received. To get back to the level he's playing at again is mind boggling."
The man has to be in his early 30's now. His time for representing Galway has come and gone sadly. I've been a big fan but he was in the Galway squad in Shefflin's tenure and didnt make the breakthrough so he is hardly going to do so now. If outstanding club form was the only consideration for inter-county selection, Ger Farragher who is now in his 40's would have been on the county panel for most of the last 10 years.

PoolSturgeon (Galway) - Posts: 2165 - 19/11/2026 22:33:25    2700843

Link

Won't engage with a lot of what's being said the last few pages but anyone who was at a Sarsfields match this year and thought any of the Cooneys should be on the panel were not paying attention.

Overdahill (Galway) - Posts: 166 - 20/11/2026 09:48:57    2700879

Link

Replying To Conntribunesh:  "Here is a toned-down version of the Galway hurling post. It keeps your core argument-that management is leaning too heavily on young U20s and overlooking proven club players from teams like Loughrea-while removing the personal digs at selectors, clubmates, and individual young players so it reads as constructive criticism and passes HoganStand moderation easily:

It is well past time that the Galway senior hurling management took a closer look at how the panel is being selected.

Right now, there is a clear bias towards familiar faces and recent U20 graduates:

A heavy proportion of the squad is drawn directly from management's own clubs, with Clarinbridge and Turloughmore making up ten spots between them, alongside further representation from Eyrecourt, Pearses, and Cappataggle.

Meanwhile, management has opted to bring through a wave of young U20s while overlooking seasoned hurlers who have consistently proven themselves at senior club level.

It is no surprise that lighter, less experienced players struggle to impose themselves against physical, battle-hardened outfits like Limerick, where the likes of Gearóid Hegarty, Kyle Hayes, Dan Morrissey, Cian Lynch, Tom Morrissey, Aaron Gillane, Shane O'Brien, and William O'Donoghue set the standard.

Management needs to put more stock in what is happening on the ground in the Galway senior club championship rather than relying so heavily on the underage pathway. Loughrea-the standout club side in the county over the last few years after completing three-in-a-row-only have two potential starters in the mix. Players like Jamie Ryan, arguably the top club hurler in Galway this season, have barely been given a fair look-in.

Truth be told, it is still the experienced core-Pádraic and Cathal Mannion, Daithí Burke, Conor Whelan, and Conor Cooney-carrying this side. Unless management starts integrating proven, physically ready club performers now, Galway hurling will face a steep drop-off once that generation steps away."
I don't know if you can edit but maybe get rid of the AI introduction which means most would stop reading.

Overdahill (Galway) - Posts: 166 - 20/11/2026 09:51:43    2700880

Link

The county team isn't a some kind of county all star team, as much as some people seem to want it to be. and such a team would obviously be a disaster as the lineup would be totally different year to year. Potential, squad balance, suitability to the game plan, tons of other stuff have to come into selection. Obviously the intenet isn't the place to do so but if you take a breath and look at the 2 years since shefflin left the role there has been a pretty fantastic job done of moving on from older players with Mac, Tuohy, Josseph cooney, jason Flynn, David Burke, Kevin Cooney, Concannon, Mcloughlin, John Cooney, Niland all moved on or retired, while team performance improved year on year.

The suggestion of bringing in players in their late to mid 20s who haven't been on county panels or ahve been there and fell away is fanciful i'm afraid. You need to be doing something truly remarkable and rightly so. A flood of u20s every year has tended to bring success for Galway under Cunningham and Donohue. it brings in a group who get exposuire to county level and the standards required, some will step up some won't.

We all love our club championship and take pride in it in galway but too much so sometimes when it comes to county selection

Overdahill (Galway) - Posts: 166 - 20/11/2026 10:05:21    2700883

Link

Replying To WanPintWin:  "That makes no sense. Ahascragh had two of our best county players for years and didn't make a dent in the senior championship. A club team needs far more than 2 or 3 top players to compete for a senior title, if the supporting cast isn't at the required level."
Excellent players win matches for teams. It is very easy to look good with poor teams. The mannions are an exception. Loughrea players are due a good look in this year. The managment need to look outide their own clubs. They have close to 15 players I reckon from their own clubs.

Conntribunesh (Galway) - Posts: 15 - 20/11/2026 10:22:27    2700888

Link

Replying To WanPintWin:  "That makes no sense. Ahascragh had two of our best county players for years and didn't make a dent in the senior championship. A club team needs far more than 2 or 3 top players to compete for a senior title, if the supporting cast isn't at the required level."
Name the players you should feel could get a right look in this year.

Conntribunesh (Galway) - Posts: 15 - 20/11/2026 10:23:39    2700889

Link

Replying To PoolSturgeon:  "The man has to be in his early 30's now. His time for representing Galway has come and gone sadly. I've been a big fan but he was in the Galway squad in Shefflin's tenure and didnt make the breakthrough so he is hardly going to do so now. If outstanding club form was the only consideration for inter-county selection, Ger Farragher who is now in his 40's would have been on the county panel for most of the last 10 years."
Exactly- all these lads mentioned have had chance on panels and didn't make the cut for whatever reason. Why would Management not pick the best players available to them, it makes no sense not to. There has to be a big emphasis on what goes on in County train sessions and Management are the only ones who see the training sessions when all these lads have been on the panels.

MoroonMan (Galway) - Posts: 109 - 20/11/2026 10:57:09    2700896

Link

Replying To BigBàsMan:  "There isnt a hurler in the county this year that would draw water to Jamie Ryan... The closest is tiernan Killeen after that club championship display. Jamie should be given a full league campaign for the Galway hurlers this year, especially after that horrific thumb injury he received. To get back to the level he's playing at again is mind boggling."
I don't think Jamie would want to be on the panel at this stage for a number of reasons!

MoroonMan (Galway) - Posts: 109 - 20/11/2026 10:58:32    2700897

Link

Comparing Jamie Ryan in his early thirties to Ger Farragher in his forties is ridiculous. Look at Limerick winning the All-Ireland this year-half that starting team are 30 or over, while we went in against them with a pile of lads under 23 and only three over 30.
Who do lads reckon will make it from u20? We were extremly poor in the final from what I can remember.

Conntribunesh (Galway) - Posts: 15 - 20/11/2026 11:23:47    2700909

Link

Replying To Overdahill:  "Won't engage with a lot of what's being said the last few pages but anyone who was at a Sarsfields match this year and thought any of the Cooneys should be on the panel were not paying attention."
I did not say they should be on the panel. I said they are in the best 5/6 players in sarsfields. Any sarsfields man will tell you that.

Conntribunesh (Galway) - Posts: 15 - 20/11/2026 11:25:30    2700911

Link

Replying To Conntribunesh:  "I did not say they should be on the panel. I said they are in the best 5/6 players in sarsfields. Any sarsfields man will tell you that."
Hard disagree there from me and I was at all bar one of sars games this year.

Overdahill (Galway) - Posts: 166 - 20/11/2026 12:20:03    2700918

Link

Replying To Conntribunesh:  "Comparing Jamie Ryan in his early thirties to Ger Farragher in his forties is ridiculous. Look at Limerick winning the All-Ireland this year-half that starting team are 30 or over, while we went in against them with a pile of lads under 23 and only three over 30.
Who do lads reckon will make it from u20? We were extremly poor in the final from what I can remember."
I don't think there's much point bringing limerick into the conversation. If we had 30 year olds with 6 all ireland medals i'm sure they'd be getting picked. The discussion about selecting lads for the first time who are in their late 20s or lads who have been on the panel previously and didn't make the cut is very different. We have been poor at u20 for a long time now and Niland & Rabbitte fairly clearly "made it" having come from those teams.

Overdahill (Galway) - Posts: 166 - 20/11/2026 12:23:15    2700921

Link