Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

National Forum

Football All Stars

(Oldest Posts First) - Go To The Latest Post

Beggan
Hessian
Foley
G Osullivan
Whittaker
McDonnell
Charlie og beirnes
Kilpatrick
Carney
Scully
Odonoghue
P Clifford
Downey
D Clifford
Beirne

royalcounty1 (Meath) - Posts: 114 - 27/07/2026 06:32:55    2687397

Link

Replying To Scenicparish:  "Even before today's match how can you name Sean O Shea ahead of Ryan O Donnaghue?"
You won't hear from that chap and another for a while I imagine ....

BarneyGrant (Dublin) - Posts: 4550 - 27/07/2026 08:11:02    2687406

Link

Replying To ColmFlaherty:  "1. Jack Livingston (Mayo)
2. Enda Hession (Mayo)
3. Donnacha McHugh (Mayo)
4. Theo Clancy (Dublin)
5. Ronan Wallace (Westmeath)
6. Dara McDonnell (Louth)
7. Charlie McMorrow (Dublin)
8. Mark O'Shea (Kerry)
9. Jack Carney (Mayo)
10. Paudie Clifford (Kerry)
11. Ryan O'Donoghue (Mayo) POTY
12. Niall Scully (Dublin)
13. Darragh Beirne (Mayo) YPOTY
14. David Clifford (Kerry)
15. Kobe McDonald (Mayo)"
I know he probably won't get an All Star but I thought Oisin Conaty was outstanding and electric all year for Armagh, scored something like 1-25 from play in 7 Championship games which is good going. Kilpatrick thought had a great year for Tyrone as well, while Darren McCurry had some great cameo appearances off the bench for them as well. But overall your team looks fairly decent enough tbh.

CartaDubh (Clare) - Posts: 62 - 27/07/2026 09:27:39    2687417

Link

This is my team of the year. (Championship & League)
Had to move couple of players around slightly as the All Star committee always do.

1. Shane Murphy ( Kerry)
2. Donnacha McHugh (Mayo)
3. Jason Foley (Kerry)
4. Charlie Mc Morrow (Dublin)
5. Matthew Whittaker ( Westmeath)
6. Dara McDonnell (Louth)
7. Enda Hession (Mayo)
8. Conn Fitzpatrick (Tyrone)
9. Jack Carney (Mayo)
10. Ryan O ' Donoghue (Mayo)
11. Paudie Clifford (Kerry)
12. Niall Scully (Dublin)
13. Diarmuid Murtagh ( Roscommon)
14. David Clifford (Kerry)
15. Darragh Beirne (Mayo)

Mayo 5
Kerry 4
Dublin 2
Louth/Roscommon/Tyrone/Westmeath all 1

letsgetgoing (Roscommon) - Posts: 962 - 27/07/2026 13:13:22    2687505

Link

Replying To letsgetgoing:  "This is my team of the year. (Championship & League)
Had to move couple of players around slightly as the All Star committee always do.

1. Shane Murphy ( Kerry)
2. Donnacha McHugh (Mayo)
3. Jason Foley (Kerry)
4. Charlie Mc Morrow (Dublin)
5. Matthew Whittaker ( Westmeath)
6. Dara McDonnell (Louth)
7. Enda Hession (Mayo)
8. Conn Fitzpatrick (Tyrone)
9. Jack Carney (Mayo)
10. Ryan O ' Donoghue (Mayo)
11. Paudie Clifford (Kerry)
12. Niall Scully (Dublin)
13. Diarmuid Murtagh ( Roscommon)
14. David Clifford (Kerry)
15. Darragh Beirne (Mayo)

Mayo 5
Kerry 4
Dublin 2
Louth/Roscommon/Tyrone/Westmeath all 1"
No players from 2026 winning team on your list?

Donegalabroad (Donegal) - Posts: 21 - 27/07/2026 13:29:30    2687508

Link

Replying To Donegalabroad:  "No players from 2026 winning team on your list?"
Unfortunately Donegal flopped after the National League final. McGee and Langan maybe a bit unlucky but don't see them shown in other selections either.

letsgetgoing (Roscommon) - Posts: 962 - 27/07/2026 13:50:05    2687514

Link

Replying To letsgetgoing:  "This is my team of the year. (Championship & League)
Had to move couple of players around slightly as the All Star committee always do.

1. Shane Murphy ( Kerry)
2. Donnacha McHugh (Mayo)
3. Jason Foley (Kerry)
4. Charlie Mc Morrow (Dublin)
5. Matthew Whittaker ( Westmeath)
6. Dara McDonnell (Louth)
7. Enda Hession (Mayo)
8. Conn Fitzpatrick (Tyrone)
9. Jack Carney (Mayo)
10. Ryan O ' Donoghue (Mayo)
11. Paudie Clifford (Kerry)
12. Niall Scully (Dublin)
13. Diarmuid Murtagh ( Roscommon)
14. David Clifford (Kerry)
15. Darragh Beirne (Mayo)

Mayo 5
Kerry 4
Dublin 2
Louth/Roscommon/Tyrone/Westmeath all 1"
Beggan all day every day for keeper for me. Murphy isn't even close to beggan's standard. Louth completely dodged a bullet with beggan being injured.

Ulsterchamps_32 (Donegal) - Posts: 1063 - 27/07/2026 13:55:39    2687517

Link

Replying To letsgetgoing:  "This is my team of the year. (Championship & League)
Had to move couple of players around slightly as the All Star committee always do.

1. Shane Murphy ( Kerry)
2. Donnacha McHugh (Mayo)
3. Jason Foley (Kerry)
4. Charlie Mc Morrow (Dublin)
5. Matthew Whittaker ( Westmeath)
6. Dara McDonnell (Louth)
7. Enda Hession (Mayo)
8. Conn Fitzpatrick (Tyrone)
9. Jack Carney (Mayo)
10. Ryan O ' Donoghue (Mayo)
11. Paudie Clifford (Kerry)
12. Niall Scully (Dublin)
13. Diarmuid Murtagh ( Roscommon)
14. David Clifford (Kerry)
15. Darragh Beirne (Mayo)

Mayo 5
Kerry 4
Dublin 2
Louth/Roscommon/Tyrone/Westmeath all 1"
Murtagh over Kobe is a bit daft in fairness..

nicko94 (Mayo) - Posts: 71 - 27/07/2026 14:39:31    2687527

Link

Replying To Donegalabroad:  "No players from 2026 winning team on your list?"
Nah! Only the league...The top teams, as you found out, were only motoring in second gear for the league. We had a higher standard of football afterwards in the Tailteann Cup, never mind the championship.

foreveryoung (USA) - Posts: 2638 - 27/07/2026 15:35:10    2687556

Link

Replying To foreveryoung:  "Nah! Only the league...The top teams, as you found out, were only motoring in second gear for the league. We had a higher standard of football afterwards in the Tailteann Cup, never mind the championship."
Dean healy from wicklow. Has it all and been doing it for years but this year was exceptional again.

ponger (Cavan) - Posts: 619 - 27/07/2026 17:30:08    2687604

Link

Replying To tirawleybaron:  "All star selectors only watch semis and final

1. All Ireland winning keeper - not Rory Beggan
2. Losing finalist corner back
3. Winners full back
4. closest losing semi finalists corner back
5. Winners wing back
6. Winner Centre back
7. Losing finalist Half back
8. Used to be utility player - but now, due to kick outs, has to be a proper midfielder - likely form non semi finalist
9. Winners midfielder
10. FF player who just didn't make ff positions
11. Utility player - player out of position to get him in the team
12. Best half forward from Champions
13. Corner forward from champions
14. Best ff from losing finalist
15. Best corner forward from losing semi finalist who doesn't already have a player on team

All Ireland champions = 7 - depending on winning margin
All Ireland R-up = 4
Best losing semi finalist = 2
Other losing semi finalist = 1
Token non semi finalist = 1"
Most of that logic went out the window in the final

1. Shane Murphy
2. Jack Coyne
3. Jason Foley
4. Enda Hession
5. Dara McDonnell
6. David McBrien
7. Ronan Wallace
8. Conn Kilpatrick
9. Jack Carney
10. Paudie Clifford
11. Ryan O Donoghue
12. Niall Scully
13. Darragh Bierne
14. David Clifford
15. Kobe McDonald

All Ireland champions = 7
All Ireland R-up = 4
Best losing semi finalist = 1
Other losing semi finalist = 1
Token non semi finalist = 1
Team with unexpected run = 1

tirawleybaron (Mayo) - Posts: 2056 - 28/07/2026 11:41:26    2687730

Link

Replying To nicko94:  "Murtagh over Kobe is a bit daft in fairness.."
Diarmuid Murtagh was outstanding in the National League and also in the championship. I presume you missed the game or had left the stadium when he scored 1-10 against Mayo in Castlebar in the Connacht championship. He was deadly with any possession he received practically all year but unfortunately none was coming in to him against Monaghan as they were totally on top out the field. (Not all his fault)

Kobe had a great year but Mayo would have won easily if he had not taken a few bad options in the final or missed a few clear-cut scores. When Mark McHugh was announcing the team of the year Diarmuid Murtagh was the first player he mentioned as being very unlucky.

I do not think that it was daft statement at all and I do not think Mark McHugh is daft either as David Clifford was always going to be selected in the full forward line.

letsgetgoing (Roscommon) - Posts: 962 - 28/07/2026 14:32:46    2687800

Link

My All Star team after some time to think.
1.Rory Began
2.Endas Hession
3.Jason Foley
4. Ronan Boyle
5.Sam Callian
6.Dara McDonnoll
7.Sam Whitaker
8.Jack Carney
9.Darren Oneill
10.Jordan Flynn
11.Ryan Odonoughe
12.Kobe McDonald
13.Darragh Bernie
14.David Clifford
15.Niall McKenna
Honourable Mention:
Paudi Clifford
Max McGinity


Manger: Andy Moran or Mark Couihnan

GAAFAN1234512345 (Monaghan) - Posts: 72 - 03/09/2026 15:10:18    2692557

Link

Great to see the spread of counties represented. Thought Whittaker was better than Wallace of Westmeaths 2 wingbacks this year. He was one of the best Footballers I saw play all year. Jarly Burns an interesting selection, great player ok but better last year. Good to see Niall Scully get one, really underrated Footballer. O'Hanlon capping a great season with an All Star is good to see too!

Viking66 (Wexford) - Posts: 20913 - 29/10/2026 10:16:56    2698835

Link

Replying To Viking66:  "Great to see the spread of counties represented. Thought Whittaker was better than Wallace of Westmeaths 2 wingbacks this year. He was one of the best Footballers I saw play all year. Jarly Burns an interesting selection, great player ok but better last year. Good to see Niall Scully get one, really underrated Footballer. O'Hanlon capping a great season with an All Star is good to see too!"
We'll just have to console ourselves by looking at the 3 Connacht football cups.

Seanfan (Roscommon) - Posts: 991 - 29/10/2026 10:48:15    2698838

Link

Replying To GAAFAN1234512345:  "My All Star team after some time to think.
1.Rory Began
2.Endas Hession
3.Jason Foley
4. Ronan Boyle
5.Sam Callian
6.Dara McDonnoll
7.Sam Whitaker
8.Jack Carney
9.Darren Oneill
10.Jordan Flynn
11.Ryan Odonoughe
12.Kobe McDonald
13.Darragh Bernie
14.David Clifford
15.Niall McKenna
Honourable Mention:
Paudi Clifford
Max McGinity


Manger: Andy Moran or Mark Couihnan"
2 monaghan only 2 kerry thats laughable. Began best keeper probably now but murphy close but he had best year in my opinion
Paudie not in is a surprise. Maybe because he isnt attending but if was dub and wasnt attending they wpuld still give them . 2 kerry is unfair .

Gaaforlife2023 (Longford) - Posts: 1387 - 29/10/2026 12:00:33    2698852

Link

Replying To Viking66:  "Great to see the spread of counties represented. Thought Whittaker was better than Wallace of Westmeaths 2 wingbacks this year. He was one of the best Footballers I saw play all year. Jarly Burns an interesting selection, great player ok but better last year. Good to see Niall Scully get one, really underrated Footballer. O'Hanlon capping a great season with an All Star is good to see too!"
Agree but paudie should be in my opinion

Gaaforlife2023 (Longford) - Posts: 1387 - 29/10/2026 12:00:58    2698853

Link

Paudie not in and charlie mc mcurrow and marc ohea unlucky More so paudie

Gaaforlife2023 (Longford) - Posts: 1387 - 29/10/2026 12:02:54    2698854

Link

Never going to please everyone anyway. I ahve no evidence but maybe thats why they left clifford out paudie easier becasue he wasnt attending.

Gaaforlife2023 (Longford) - Posts: 1387 - 29/10/2026 12:04:44    2698855

Link

Replying To Viking66:  "Great to see the spread of counties represented. Thought Whittaker was better than Wallace of Westmeaths 2 wingbacks this year. He was one of the best Footballers I saw play all year. Jarly Burns an interesting selection, great player ok but better last year. Good to see Niall Scully get one, really underrated Footballer. O'Hanlon capping a great season with an All Star is good to see too!"
The criteria must have changed dramatically. An All Star to a player whose team didn't even get to play in Croke Park at all in the Championship. Won one game in the round robin and beaten in a prelim QF. That doesn't add up!

Dualstar22 (Galway) - Posts: 34 - 29/10/2026 12:08:09    2698857

Link