National Forum

Round Robin Groups Of 4 - Open Draw Or Not?

(Oldest Posts First)

The draw for the group stage will involve the provincial winners as seeds 1, the provincial runners-up as seeds 2, etc. with a draw of some kind giving 4 groups, each group consisting of a seed 1, a seed 2, a seed 3 and a seed 4.
The GAA Master Calendar states that "SFC RR1 (Involving CSFC & MSFC Finalists)" takes place on May 20/21 and "SFC RR1 (Involving LSFC & USFC Finalists) takes place on May 27/28. All of which suggests that some element of seeding must take place in selecting the groups i.e. not an open draw.
The whole thing seems to be shrouded in mystery.

Aibrean (Kerry) - Posts: 263 - 14/04/2023 18:36:14    2471019

Link

Replying To Aibrean:  "The draw for the group stage will involve the provincial winners as seeds 1, the provincial runners-up as seeds 2, etc. with a draw of some kind giving 4 groups, each group consisting of a seed 1, a seed 2, a seed 3 and a seed 4.
The GAA Master Calendar states that "SFC RR1 (Involving CSFC & MSFC Finalists)" takes place on May 20/21 and "SFC RR1 (Involving LSFC & USFC Finalists) takes place on May 27/28. All of which suggests that some element of seeding must take place in selecting the groups i.e. not an open draw.
The whole thing seems to be shrouded in mystery."
That Connacht/Munster thing is apparently contrary to what the Rules in TO lay down so it may in fact be an open draw apart from repeats of Provincial Finals.
3rd seeds will be
Mayo
Losers Ros/Galway
2 from Derry/Monaghan/Tyrone.

Seanfanbocht (Roscommon) - Posts: 1413 - 15/04/2023 12:16:26    2471052

Link

Replying To Aibrean:  "The draw for the group stage will involve the provincial winners as seeds 1, the provincial runners-up as seeds 2, etc. with a draw of some kind giving 4 groups, each group consisting of a seed 1, a seed 2, a seed 3 and a seed 4.
The GAA Master Calendar states that "SFC RR1 (Involving CSFC & MSFC Finalists)" takes place on May 20/21 and "SFC RR1 (Involving LSFC & USFC Finalists) takes place on May 27/28. All of which suggests that some element of seeding must take place in selecting the groups i.e. not an open draw.
The whole thing seems to be shrouded in mystery."
To answer my own question.
It now seems that it is an open draw. For example, Kerry (if they win Munster) will not automatically be paired with Sligo/NY (if they lose Connacht Final.
The Master Calendar should have said 'Winners' instead of 'Finalists'.

Aibrean (Kerry) - Posts: 263 - 15/04/2023 15:00:40    2471073

Link