(Oldest Posts First) - Go To The Latest Post
When the referee realised that the substituted player had not gone off, what should he have done, the game was still on at that stage, what rule should the ref follow. In 2021 the referee ordered a missed Mayo 45 to be retaken when he realised "Mayo" had 16 players on the field even though the offending Mayoman was almost off and a long way behind the play, this decision cost Dublin a place in the final and there was SFA from the sports journalists about it. sligo joe (Dublin) - Posts: 677 - 24/01/2023 13:39:52 2453951 Link 3 |
They'll appeal alright. But they're highlighting the fact it shouldn't be up to them and will wait until the last minute. They'd be mad not to, a rule broken and God knows when they'll get a chance again at an All Ireland. They won't lose any 'honour' appealing. They're totally within their right. This is controversial but Meath lost honour in 2010. Laois gave Carlow a rematch for the point that never was in 1995. Meath came out of 2010 badly. No two ways about it. Even Trevor Giles and ex players came out and said so. Most neutrals were delighted when Meath were beaten by Kildare in 2010. CC2020 (Kilkenny) - Posts: 173 - 24/01/2023 13:43:21 2453954 Link 1 |
It would be interesting to see the referee's report. He was aware of the incident and ordered the substituted player off the pitch prior to final kickout. If he makes no references to it in his report, then I cannot see the CCCC intervening unless there is an objection. I think that the CCCC can only review disciplinary issues on the field of play. Perhaps in light of this and other technicalities which has arisen in the recent pass, the role of the CCCC should be reviewed. Could be a very busy time for them. Congress can only review this when the motion is submitted to them. . B&G (Longford) - Posts: 276 - 24/01/2023 13:52:25 2453957 Link 1 |
Just the ones that mention "objection" or "objecting." Not that difficult really,
BarneyGrant (Dublin) - Posts: 2554 - 24/01/2023 14:03:33 2453960 Link 0 |
"At minimum." So you think the team that won should be made lose over what was an officiating error? Glen are not claiming that, because they are not claiming that they were beaten because of that error. They do have a case, but not to have the match result reversed in their favour, as much as the anti Dubs might wish. BarneyGrant (Dublin) - Posts: 2554 - 24/01/2023 14:06:23 2453962 Link 0 |
I reckon it's about time somebody addressed the accusations that GAA top brass are shirking responsibility by saying it's up to Glen to lodge an appeal. Pikeman96 (Wexford) - Posts: 2245 - 24/01/2023 14:25:29 2453969 Link 1 |
Do you think there might be a conspiracy at play here?
greatpoint (USA) - Posts: 427 - 24/01/2023 14:28:58 2453971 Link 0 |
According to Irish Examiner it's not mentioned in referee's report which is surprising and doesn't help the Glen case. Hard to fathom why ref didn't mention it as he was totally innocent of any mistake, also difficult to know how John Fogarty in Examiner seems to know this as referee's report is surely only seen by a couple of people. It's not the first time Fogarty has inside knowledge of refereeing matters. Claretandblue (Westmeath) - Posts: 1489 - 24/01/2023 14:35:09 2453974 Link 0 |
I couldnt give a toss who wins this all ireland (or any garlic football game for that matter) but my major concern is what ever happens will set a precedent that may be used in hurling in the future re the 16th man. Therefore I think it has to be replayed. clare_sparrow (Galway) - Posts: 425 - 24/01/2023 14:37:41 2453975 Link 5 |
A replay is the only fair and just outcome in my opinion. The GAA have not covered themselves in glory so far here at all, the decision should be taken out of the clubs' hands and a replay ordered. LetterkennyMan (Donegal) - Posts: 393 - 24/01/2023 14:38:06 2453976 Link 2 |
Don't be talking sense now Pikeman, One of best comments I heard on all of this - in which there are NO winners at this stage- was chap who said that everything now seems to descend into soundbites that are only marginally connected to the facts. Which include the relevant rule as quoted, and the undoubted fact that Glen have a case. However, as shown it is one they have to make themselves, BarneyGrant (Dublin) - Posts: 2554 - 24/01/2023 14:46:27 2453977 Link 0 |
I am not the one alleging that there is! That's all on the other side. Not on the part of Glen. Two teams are basically innocent and I have consistently agreed that Glen have a case, but as Pikeman and others - including chap here who was on CCCC - have pointed out, the Rule is pretty clear. Croke Park can only act on an objection and they have held that line consistently. I imagine Glen will appeal, and that they will win that appeal and that there will be a replay. I also imagine that Glen be far less enthusiastic about this than some of the wailers from the interweb, including a certain pundit who is the epitome of the politician who is alleged to have asked what way the mob was heading so that he could lead them there. BarneyGrant (Dublin) - Posts: 2554 - 24/01/2023 14:51:40 2453982 Link 0 |
A replay is the only fair and just outcome in my opinion. The GAA have not covered themselves in glory so far here at all, the decision should be taken out of the clubs' hands and a replay ordered. LetterkennyMan (Donegal) - Posts: 393 - 24/01/2023 14:52:13 2453983 Link 2 |
I'm hoping glen lodge an objection..this will force the Gaa to make a bloody decision..not a word from Larry mc carthy on the matter..he's suppose to be the top man of organization..the Gaa havnt been slow in putting up prices for people going to league matches,but can't make a decision on this..I have absolutely nothing against crokes but rules are rules.. CTGAA10 (Limerick) - Posts: 2214 - 24/01/2023 15:01:23 2453986 Link 1 |
Yes, it was an officiating error but Crokes were also guilty of a very basic error - you can't play with 16 players.
midlands (Westmeath) - Posts: 542 - 24/01/2023 15:07:35 2453987 Link 1 |
I think the GAA will fine Croke's as it's in the rule book and that will be the end of it. Remember team's , if your a point or two up in dying seconds and there's a 50 against you, throw on an extra player.
Saynothing (Tyrone) - Posts: 2012 - 24/01/2023 15:08:17 2453988 Link 2 |
If Glen are so annoyed let them object and quit fooling around the thing? It is dragging on now and if they want a replay please object soon and get it done with as it is very tiresome at this stage. I think Malachy O Rourke has stated that he does not want a replay so doubt the club will go against Malacher lusciousleitrim (Leitrim) - Posts: 7 - 24/01/2023 15:22:40 2453995 Link 0 |
And hopefully Glen won't turn up for the replay and that will show up the GAA for what they really are.
Breffni1969 (Cavan) - Posts: 510 - 24/01/2023 15:24:18 2453996 Link 1 |
Is there no rule saying that Football is a 15 a side game? And what is the penalty if that rule is broken?
Viking66 (Wexford) - Posts: 11842 - 24/01/2023 15:37:35 2454002 Link 1 |
The hurling man speaketh. It shall therefore be done. Thank you for guiding us, hurling man. I agree with you by the way that it should b3 replayed. WanPintWin (Galway) - Posts: 2039 - 24/01/2023 15:41:14 2454003 Link 2 |