National Forum

A Title Of Substance

(Oldest Posts First) - Go To The Latest Post


Replying To Cockney_Cat:  "Kilkenny are not the first team to appear in an All-Ireland final after losing two games."
I know that Cockney. I was just making the point that in spite of that Kilkenny would have been thrilled to win it.

CiarraiMick (Dublin) - Posts: 3675 - 30/07/2022 20:36:54    2435531

Link

Replying To points50swiththeargyllsonthewrongfeet:  "The begrudgery is out there folks. When we won on 03, it was down to "puke football" and doing un-GAA stuff like swarm defending. Of course, now that everyone else has adopted a similar defensive approach, there's not a word about it.
Tyrone's win last year was of course similarly downplayed. The dominant narrative was that Kerry and Mayo lost it, rather than Tyrone won it. Pat Spillane said recently that, last year v Tyrone, Kerry had an off day, and "didn't show up". That is, the result had little to do with Tyrone, Kerry just didn't "show up". As for the final, well, Tyone won mainly because, remarkably, Mayo had an off day too, and missed lots of scores they normally would have got. The fact that Tyrone may have pressured the life out of them is overlooked. As the ever-gracious Martin Breheny said in March this year, writing in a national newspaper, Tyrone were "accidental champs, gifted the throne". In other words, a cheap all Ireland for Tyrone, who just got lucky in that their semi-final and final opponents both played well below their normal standards. It's almost as if Tyrone are unacceptable at the top table, and you can sense the relief when we're knocked out of the championship.
I love this, and pray that the begrudgery continues. The Tyrone psyche responds badly to praise and to popularity ..."
There is a but of begrudgery but also a bit of self pity and you have that me thinks. Most people don't take Spillane serious. It was he that COI Ed the "puke football" but so what. I'm a Kerryman. A proud Kerryman and I will admit I did nt like Tyrone s style v Kerry in 03 but Tyrone were better team. In 05vand O8 Tyrone played brilliant entertaining football and again Tyrone were the better team. Last year was a very close game and I thought Kerry were nt as bad as made out. We actually outscored Tyrone but Tyrone got 3 goals. Also Tyrone played some great football and Niall Morgan was special that day. I give Tyrone their deserved dues as do many people I know. You can't control the narrative of many people s view. I used to have self pity too when folk used to say Kerry won handy all Irelands. I can't change that. Enjoy your wins. I know I do.

CiarraiMick (Dublin) - Posts: 3675 - 30/07/2022 20:44:04    2435532

Link