National Forum

Donegal GAA thread

(Oldest Posts First) - Go To The Latest Post


Replying To peiledoir20:  "Definitely unfair to call him a free kick merchant but I feel he has been over hyped. His biggest haul came against New York a couple of years ago. He probably looks a bit better given the rest of the Mayo forwards fall so short. Roarty marshalled him well yesterday and even outscored him from play."
He doesn't score enough from play in big games but always has a big total in league and championship. Most of his scores are from Frees. No one hypes him apart from Mayo fans. If that is their marquee forward for the next while, they'll struggle to win a Connacht never mind an all Ireland.

eddieSize5Balls (Donegal) - Posts: 292 - 16/02/2026 19:04:23    2656877

Link

Replying To eddieSize5Balls:  "Mayo always have excuses when they lose even from our own fans. We should be beating Roscommon and Monaghan and if we do, with 10 points we lost certainly would be in a final. So a final definitely is on the horizon.
Armagh have been poor lately too and Galway would be a toss up.


Mulreaney was good but he's not going to displace Patton, let's be serious. Pattons kickouts are the best in the country.

The new young boys did it well. We should have a good u20 year it would seem.

I am still holding out some hope Paddy is coaxed back for championship."
Lol...you couldn't wait to retire him 2 years ago!!!

chancer (Donegal) - Posts: 37 - 16/02/2026 20:12:28    2656891

Link

Replying To Commodore:  "I'd need to see the stats from both for proper comparison on kick-outs, Mulreanny isn't bad at short or medium range, and he saved us from conceding a couple of goals in the 2nd half yesterday.

Patton has that long-range ability if the opposition do press up, but most teams counteract that now by pushing the keeper out to the 45 for kickouts. But its still a serious threat to have within our arsenal, as you never know when a team might leave that gap exposed."
Gavin Mulreany has been a credit to himself in this league campaign but respectively when Patton is back the number 1 spot will be his again. Military precision from kickouts is the single most important part of the new rules. I wouldn't go as far as Geezer to call it "piggery", but you have to give yourself every chance on the kickout under the new rules. Patton has a longer range and is more capable of picking a man. I think in this regard we have played to Mulreanys strengths in the last 3 games, but I also don't think it's coincidence that all 3 of our opponents copped on to us in the second half of each fixture.

This isn't a comment on Gavin or Sean, but I think it's something we got badly wrong in July against Kerry. We had two games of evidence whereby they hijacked Tyrone and Armagh's kickout, and we left High and Jason on the bench. I can see where management were coming from trying to keep something in reserve but it was too little too late. I'm also not so naive as to ignore the fact that Ryan and Ciaran were unfortunately lost far too early in the game (especially Ciaran T for fielding and twos), and I won't imply that the final was lost on one dimension rather than being a culmination of several things going against us. I do however think that Jim is taking a once bitten twice shy approach by loading up the middle with big men.

To support that, I think we end up going with the keeper most capable of servicing them and Gavin Mulreany is very unfortunate to have such a keeper as Sean Patton ahead of him. And we are very lucky to have such a capable deputy

papa_pump (Donegal) - Posts: 90 - 16/02/2026 21:48:41    2656914

Link

Replying To chancer:  "Lol...you couldn't wait to retire him 2 years ago!!!"
He was finished as a starter long ago but He can offer something from the bench

eddieSize5Balls (Donegal) - Posts: 292 - 17/02/2026 00:14:04    2656928

Link

A great start to the year with a 100% record across the McKenna Cup and National League.
We're more or less safe now which is objective number 1 achieved. This weekend will be interesting. It would be nice to beat Armagh for a number of reasons,
1. Because beating Armagh is always nice.
2. It keeps our momentum going.
3. Lays down another wee psychological marker. as good as Armagh have been in recent years, they can't ever seem to get the better of us.
4. It puts Armagh under a wee bit of pressure in terms of Div 1 status.

Beyond that, it will be good to see some squad members get some game time.

I'd just be a wee bit nervous about all the plamás we're getting nationally at the moment. Winning games in the Spring is great and all, but as we know it's the summer when the real action starts. But, all in all, a great time to be a Donegal supporter, long may it continue.

Just a side note - interesting to hear that Darragh Canavan is heading away to Australia for a month. The timing is interesting. Does it hint that Tyrone don't consider themselves realistic contenders? I know the chat is that he'll be home for Championship, but a month out of training and competitive action at this time of year isn't great preparation for one of their star men?

Lockjaw (Donegal) - Posts: 10238 - 17/02/2026 10:10:53    2656958

Link

Paddy's knee is goosed, he'll hardly be playing for the Kilcar ones never mind Donegal in the championship

ModernMaharaja (Donegal) - Posts: 134 - 17/02/2026 11:00:48    2656971

Link

Replying To eddieSize5Balls:  "He was finished as a starter long ago but He can offer something from the bench"
Retired because of injury. Time to look forward with the new players.

greenfan (Donegal) - Posts: 754 - 17/02/2026 11:25:20    2656975

Link

I watched many older people arriving at the ground very early on Sunday and still not getting a seat.There were a lot of young fit people and indeed a lot of coats in the seats which hardly seems fair but perhaps unavoidable.You cannot expect huge seating capacity at secondary grounds such as Letterkenny or Ballyshannon but you probably would have had the same situation in Ballybofey.This got me thinking that all county grounds should have far more covered seating.The majority of county grounds would have about 3-5k seats on one side of the ground.I don't know what this would cost but it is something we should be aiming for in this day and age.Maybe if the other side of the field was covered without seats??.It is a long stand for older supporters on a wet winters day.If it was a bus or train fitter people would be giving up their seats.

gunman (Donegal) - Posts: 1227 - 17/02/2026 14:54:17    2657008

Link

Replying To chancer:  "Lol...you couldn't wait to retire him 2 years ago!!!"
The same experts were saying hugh mc fadden was never a county player a good few years ago..

rorysboys (Donegal) - Posts: 2686 - 17/02/2026 15:29:20    2657014

Link

Replying To Commodore:  "I wouldn't get too carried away with chat of League finals, Mayo were not at full strength and the elements was a factor that first half. We got Dublin on opening league match, they came back strong at us and a understrength Kerry side came back strong at us, as did Mayo yesterday. We have tough games against Armagh, Galway, Roscommon and Monaghan still ahead. I would expect at least 3 of those teams to present a more complete 70 minute performance and not allow us to get ahead at HT, which will be likely if we are fielding more inexperienced players in those games for long periods.

Mulreaney is really challenging for a starting place in the summer, in fact, I think Shaun Patton will be fighting now to get back in the team.

McCahill had a brilliant debut, definitely looks like a bright addition, both him and Shea Malone injecting energy into our attack. Defensively"
I don't think talk of getting to a league final is getting carried away with those remaining fixtures. The challenges will be welcome especially if there are big rotations. Looking forward to seeing what the more inexperienced lads do and where it takes us. However I would agree in not getting too carried away in the scheme of overall things at this time of the year.

panamasam (Australia) - Posts: 2910 - 17/02/2026 17:22:19    2657027

Link

Replying To rorysboys:  "The same experts were saying hugh mc fadden was never a county player a good few years ago.."
To be fair, he wasn't of the standard of a team capable of winning an all-ireland. Too slow to change direction, which half forwards and forwards knew and exploited, slow in general, and didn't have the fitness required, or at least the ability to use his energy smartly throughout a game. That said, I believe he's the most improved player under Jim, which meant that he was capable, but wasn't putting in the work, or the right work. Hats off to him. He's earned his place this year and last.
Paddy, with such a stellar service stayed at least one year too long. He was ineffective against the better teams, at the business end. This had the effect, along with playing Jamie who long lost his spark of not being able to expose the new generation of forwards to playing at the highest level. It was a tactical misstep, gambling on experience but this year were doing what should have been done last year.

StockholmGael (Donegal) - Posts: 149 - 17/02/2026 19:54:13    2657042

Link

Replying To gunman:  "I watched many older people arriving at the ground very early on Sunday and still not getting a seat.There were a lot of young fit people and indeed a lot of coats in the seats which hardly seems fair but perhaps unavoidable.You cannot expect huge seating capacity at secondary grounds such as Letterkenny or Ballyshannon but you probably would have had the same situation in Ballybofey.This got me thinking that all county grounds should have far more covered seating.The majority of county grounds would have about 3-5k seats on one side of the ground.I don't know what this would cost but it is something we should be aiming for in this day and age.Maybe if the other side of the field was covered without seats??.It is a long stand for older supporters on a wet winters day.If it was a bus or train fitter people would be giving up their seats."
The side opposite the Stand was in very poor condition, absolutely no gravel on it, and water running down the slope leaving muck and dirt down the front. What you gain from O'Donnell Park with the Stand you lose on the terrace in comparison with Ballyshannon. Hopefully McCumhaill Park will be ready for Championship or else there is going to be a lot of disappointed supporters.

On the match itself I thought we were really on it in the first half. The levels dropped on the 2nd, but all in all a really slick display. Armagh will no doubt be up for this week and will bring another level of physicality.

SouthOfTheGap (Donegal) - Posts: 896 - 17/02/2026 20:02:27    2657044

Link

Replying To gunman:  "I watched many older people arriving at the ground very early on Sunday and still not getting a seat.There were a lot of young fit people and indeed a lot of coats in the seats which hardly seems fair but perhaps unavoidable.You cannot expect huge seating capacity at secondary grounds such as Letterkenny or Ballyshannon but you probably would have had the same situation in Ballybofey.This got me thinking that all county grounds should have far more covered seating.The majority of county grounds would have about 3-5k seats on one side of the ground.I don't know what this would cost but it is something we should be aiming for in this day and age.Maybe if the other side of the field was covered without seats??.It is a long stand for older supporters on a wet winters day.If it was a bus or train fitter people would be giving up their seats."
100% agree on the extra seating, but the GAA is backwards in how does things, and the comfort of the diehard GAA fans is nowhere near top of their priority list, despite the good aul GAA fan being the primary funder of the association. A lot of people skip matches because of existing facilities at GAA grounds, like if the weather is a bit iffy, just not appealing.

It's not confined to Donegal either. Take Casement Park for example, you never ever will hear anything about the needs of Ulster GAA fans when they are talking about it, always about how Belfast City needs a GAA stadium because the Unionists have their stadiums or some Rugby or Soccer event needs it. Rarely would someone say that we need modern GAA stadium with better facilities for comfort of the Ulster GAA fans etc.

Commodore (Donegal) - Posts: 1613 - 17/02/2026 23:22:13    2657060

Link

Replying To panamasam:  "I don't think talk of getting to a league final is getting carried away with those remaining fixtures. The challenges will be welcome especially if there are big rotations. Looking forward to seeing what the more inexperienced lads do and where it takes us. However I would agree in not getting too carried away in the scheme of overall things at this time of the year."
I agree its possible, but I was saying that because we will likely be giving a lot of the fringe players more game time to see who can consistently make the cut this year come Championship.

I agree that we can go toe to toe with all of these sides when we are at full strength, all of those sides are capable of getting results against us if we field weakened teams. Armagh know us inside out, they will be reeling after the Roscommon result, Galway look to be getting stronger match by match, they will be a handful. Roscommon and Monaghan are both well capable of scalping us if we under-perform or field a weakened side.

I'd prefer full focus should be on winning Ulster Championship this year, that would be our first ever 3 in a row in Ulster, and 6/7 Ulster Championships for Jim McGuinness as manager. Then hopefully have a tilt for the All Ireland if all goes well.

Commodore (Donegal) - Posts: 1613 - 17/02/2026 23:32:30    2657061

Link

I know it's maybe a bit trite to say it, but if there was ever a Donegal player who "deserves" a Celtic Cross medal it's the likes of Hugh McFadden. (I'd put Ryan McHugh in the same category)
They both came on the scene after the 2012 win, and have soldiered on for years in the good times and bad. We're certainly in contention in 2026, but a wee bit of luck is needed and when it comes to the business end of things, that other old GAA cliche "all on the day" can often come into it.

I think every knowledgable GAA person in the county always acknowledged the effort Hugh put in. But happily for him, he has elevated his game almost beyond all recognition in recent years. Absolute credit to him.

Lockjaw (Donegal) - Posts: 10238 - 18/02/2026 12:06:55    2657107

Link

Replying To rorysboys:  "The same experts were saying hugh mc fadden was never a county player a good few years ago.."
Hugh brings physicality , hard work and strength to the midfield sector . Brought stability and parity when introduced in last years All Ireland … unfortunately Donegal we're playing catch up when he came on. Was it a mistake not to have him in the starting 15 ?
Hugh's presence also frees up the stylish Michael Langan to operate at centre half forward where he gets a little more room to use his skills set, pace , distribution and 2 point kicking ability.
Donegal are in the fortunate position of being relatively safe to try out different combinations, tactics and new players in the remaining fixtures … can see a long Summer ahead for them.

Curlew66 (Roscommon) - Posts: 644 - 18/02/2026 12:30:57    2657114

Link

Hugh is the most improved player since Jim came back I think, he is such an honest fella, he gives us all for the cause as they all do I know,
Paddy was also a great servant to this county and he has his Celtic cross in his back pocket plus a hat full of Ulster medals. I don't think we'll see him return for Championship this year but stranger things have happened.
I'd love to see Hugh and Ryan win All Ireland medals before they retire, but as the man said deserve has got nothing to do with it, many great players from all counties never won those medals.
I remember the great Kerry team of the 70's -80's era, many of them I think stayed on too long and it didn't help the chances of younger players there trying to break into their senior team, Kerry went into the doldrums a bit after that.
Big challenge in Armagh next Sunday, I expect Jim will use the squad more from here on as we are safe now in div one I think.

Tirchonaill1 (Donegal) - Posts: 3708 - 18/02/2026 14:11:57    2657138

Link

I would like one more victory before we experiment too much.After all Tyrone went down on 7 points last year.If we get to the league Final either by design or by chance it shouldn't do us any wile harm.We have 4 weeks to the Down game.We were in the League Final in 2024 and 3 weeks later we beat Derry in Celtic Park.

gunman (Donegal) - Posts: 1227 - 18/02/2026 14:54:25    2657153

Link

Replying To gunman:  "I would like one more victory before we experiment too much.After all Tyrone went down on 7 points last year.If we get to the league Final either by design or by chance it shouldn't do us any wile harm.We have 4 weeks to the Down game.We were in the League Final in 2024 and 3 weeks later we beat Derry in Celtic Park."
Oh definitely, the extra game outside championship would be welcomed, especially with players coming back from Injury.

Commodore (Donegal) - Posts: 1613 - 18/02/2026 17:32:49    2657198

Link