National Forum

Galway Hurling thread

(Oldest Posts First) - Go To The Latest Post


Replying To katser:  "11pts up at half time v Antrim, 0-04 from C Cooney. Bad luck for C Mannion hamstring gone again!"
Kevin Cooneys goal must of warmed your heart Kaster. Darren Morrissey to Joseph Cooney to Kevin Cooney back to Joseph back to Kevin. Bang into the net. Goal made proudly in New Inn/Bullaun.

SamandLiamSoon (Galway) - Posts: 589 - 21/05/2023 18:51:13    2480122

Link

Any work on the injured players? Will mannion be out for long? He is vital to our season

ecad123 (Galway) - Posts: 272 - 22/05/2023 00:16:17    2480262

Link

Replying To PoolSturgeon:  "Of course we need to get something out of it. On all known form Kilkenny will beat Wexford and will end up on 9 points. If Dublin beat us both teams will finish on 7 points and Dublin will be in through to the Leinster final by virtue of the head to head result."
Dumb question here but if Galway lose to Dublin are they out of the Championship or would they have to play someone from the Munster Group?

Trump2020 (Galway) - Posts: 2119 - 22/05/2023 00:43:19    2480265

Link

Replying To galway19:  "How in the name of god did Wexford just lose to Westmeath? They looked an appalling outfit when we played them in Mullingar."
I got ridiculed a few weeks back here by some Wexford lads for saying they were useless. I now apologise for being wrong. They are worse than useless. they are pathetic.

clare_sparrow (Galway) - Posts: 425 - 22/05/2023 08:51:39    2480293

Link

I see that poor auld Liam Sheedy is "not convinced" about Galway on TSG but had "praise" for the Munster teams who were "competitive" and "consistent" even though Galway have been one of the most "consistent" teams in the last 7 or 8 years. He also stated that Galway now have to win "4 more matches" and can they do it - he obviously doesn't remember 2017 or most of the recent Galway championship matches with his native Tipp! Have Clare, Cork, Waterford, Wexford and Dublin been that consistent in the last few years? No but that doesn't matter to Liam as he and most Munster based pundits "don't like Galway" which is the main reason behind his rant! He also praised the "high quality" of the Munster championship compared to Leinster and elsewhere John Mullane states "something has to change re the lopsided competitive structures of Munster and Leinster that favours KK and Galway" but they still want the Munster championship to "stay the same". I think all these so called "pundits" need to be a bit more "consistent" themselves and not say one thing and then use the other side of their mouth to say the exact opposite! lol

tommy k (Galway) - Posts: 3320 - 22/05/2023 12:16:01    2480443

Link

Replying To Trump2020:  "Dumb question here but if Galway lose to Dublin are they out of the Championship or would they have to play someone from the Munster Group?"
We'd be third in Leinster in that case, so our route would be:
Preliminary quarter-final vs Joe McDonagh finalist
Quarter-final vs Munster runner-up
Semi-final vs Leinster champions

WanPintWin (Galway) - Posts: 2039 - 22/05/2023 12:29:17    2480453

Link

Replying To galway19:  "How in the name of god did Wexford just lose to Westmeath? They looked an appalling outfit when we played them in Mullingar."
In fairness wexford didn't look too good in the stadium either.
A Laois, carlow, kerry etc would fancy taking wexford on at this stage,, hopefully it's only temporary,, there are few enough top hurling counties as it is without losing the ones we have.

Galway9801 (Galway) - Posts: 1705 - 22/05/2023 12:59:04    2480477

Link

Replying To WanPintWin:  "We'd be third in Leinster in that case, so our route would be:
Preliminary quarter-final vs Joe McDonagh finalist
Quarter-final vs Munster runner-up
Semi-final vs Leinster champions"
Will it definitely be against the Leinster Champions in the semi-final?
If the 3rd placed team in Munster also makes it through to the semis, won't they play the LC, and Galway play the Munster Champions.

Cockney_Cat (UK) - Posts: 2458 - 22/05/2023 13:16:48    2480490

Link

Replying To tommy k:  "I see that poor auld Liam Sheedy is "not convinced" about Galway on TSG but had "praise" for the Munster teams who were "competitive" and "consistent" even though Galway have been one of the most "consistent" teams in the last 7 or 8 years. He also stated that Galway now have to win "4 more matches" and can they do it - he obviously doesn't remember 2017 or most of the recent Galway championship matches with his native Tipp! Have Clare, Cork, Waterford, Wexford and Dublin been that consistent in the last few years? No but that doesn't matter to Liam as he and most Munster based pundits "don't like Galway" which is the main reason behind his rant! He also praised the "high quality" of the Munster championship compared to Leinster and elsewhere John Mullane states "something has to change re the lopsided competitive structures of Munster and Leinster that favours KK and Galway" but they still want the Munster championship to "stay the same". I think all these so called "pundits" need to be a bit more "consistent" themselves and not say one thing and then use the other side of their mouth to say the exact opposite! lol"
In fairness, tommy, the only time it's worth taking any notice of Mullane is to laugh at him.

He was also trying to tell us on RTÉ Radio that Cork are a 'coming team'.....

This ia a 'coming team' with an attack containing Harnedy, Horgan and Lehane all starting.

Three men with a great future behind them. Cork might be 'coming' but they are 'going' nowhere fast while they are starting the fossils.

He could see this yet parrotted the 'Cork are coming' line. He's a joke.

Stool Pigeon (Galway) - Posts: 832 - 22/05/2023 14:03:27    2480514

Link

Replying To Cockney_Cat:  "Will it definitely be against the Leinster Champions in the semi-final?
If the 3rd placed team in Munster also makes it through to the semis, won't they play the LC, and Galway play the Munster Champions."
3rd place in Munster (if they beat the Joe McDonagh runner-up and the Leinster final loser) would play the Munster winner.
3rd place in Leinster (if they beat the Joe McDonagh winner and Munster final loser) would play the Leinster winner.

It ensures that the provincial finalists can't meet each other in the All-Ireland semis.

WanPintWin (Galway) - Posts: 2039 - 22/05/2023 14:25:10    2480534

Link

Replying To Stool Pigeon:  "In fairness, tommy, the only time it's worth taking any notice of Mullane is to laugh at him.

He was also trying to tell us on RTÉ Radio that Cork are a 'coming team'.....

This ia a 'coming team' with an attack containing Harnedy, Horgan and Lehane all starting.

Three men with a great future behind them. Cork might be 'coming' but they are 'going' nowhere fast while they are starting the fossils.

He could see this yet parrotted the 'Cork are coming' line. He's a joke."
I agree but its still very annoying to be listening to these Munster pundits like Sheedy and Mullane with a chip on their shoulder re Galway in general and hurling in particular - its not just my imagination anymore!

tommy k (Galway) - Posts: 3320 - 22/05/2023 14:33:44    2480538

Link

Replying To tommy k:  "I see that poor auld Liam Sheedy is "not convinced" about Galway on TSG but had "praise" for the Munster teams who were "competitive" and "consistent" even though Galway have been one of the most "consistent" teams in the last 7 or 8 years. He also stated that Galway now have to win "4 more matches" and can they do it - he obviously doesn't remember 2017 or most of the recent Galway championship matches with his native Tipp! Have Clare, Cork, Waterford, Wexford and Dublin been that consistent in the last few years? No but that doesn't matter to Liam as he and most Munster based pundits "don't like Galway" which is the main reason behind his rant! He also praised the "high quality" of the Munster championship compared to Leinster and elsewhere John Mullane states "something has to change re the lopsided competitive structures of Munster and Leinster that favours KK and Galway" but they still want the Munster championship to "stay the same". I think all these so called "pundits" need to be a bit more "consistent" themselves and not say one thing and then use the other side of their mouth to say the exact opposite! lol"
I was expecting this might irk one or two! I'm not his biggest fan but hes just giving an opinion and you're points dont really show anything to say hes wrong. This is the sixth season since Galway won the All Ireland. I'd be laughed out of the place If I suggested anything Tipp done in 2019 mattered now.
You've named a whole host of counties there who literally no one has as AI contenders. Galway have been inconsistent within games never mind within seasons since 2017. The fact Galway have usually been really good against TIpp actually backs up his point perfectly.
For what its worth, Galway are contenders in my opinion and they also can lose the next two and still be two wins from an All Ireland final place

tiobraid (Tipperary) - Posts: 4119 - 22/05/2023 14:34:21    2480539

Link

Replying To Stool Pigeon:  "In fairness, tommy, the only time it's worth taking any notice of Mullane is to laugh at him.

He was also trying to tell us on RTÉ Radio that Cork are a 'coming team'.....

This ia a 'coming team' with an attack containing Harnedy, Horgan and Lehane all starting.

Three men with a great future behind them. Cork might be 'coming' but they are 'going' nowhere fast while they are starting the fossils.

He could see this yet parrotted the 'Cork are coming' line. He's a joke."
Of course John wants the Munster Championship to stay the same. Waterford would've been relegated after 3/4 of the Round Robins ever played if not.

Viking66 (Wexford) - Posts: 11815 - 22/05/2023 14:35:00    2480541

Link

Replying To PoolSturgeon:  "Of course we need to get something out of it. On all known form Kilkenny will beat Wexford and will end up on 9 points. If Dublin beat us both teams will finish on 7 points and Dublin will be in through to the Leinster final by virtue of the head to head result."
Say a Wexford and Dublin win, what way does that leave who's in final?

CillTormoir (Galway) - Posts: 487 - 22/05/2023 14:53:05    2480551

Link

Replying To Stool Pigeon:  "In fairness, tommy, the only time it's worth taking any notice of Mullane is to laugh at him.

He was also trying to tell us on RTÉ Radio that Cork are a 'coming team'.....

This ia a 'coming team' with an attack containing Harnedy, Horgan and Lehane all starting.

Three men with a great future behind them. Cork might be 'coming' but they are 'going' nowhere fast while they are starting the fossils.

He could see this yet parrotted the 'Cork are coming' line. He's a joke."
Fossils?!! Do you say the same about the older guys on the Galway team? I'd imagine Galway have an average age as high as anyone in the cship.
Fairly harsh comment.

tiobraid (Tipperary) - Posts: 4119 - 22/05/2023 14:58:54    2480558

Link

Replying To tiobraid:  "I was expecting this might irk one or two! I'm not his biggest fan but hes just giving an opinion and you're points dont really show anything to say hes wrong. This is the sixth season since Galway won the All Ireland. I'd be laughed out of the place If I suggested anything Tipp done in 2019 mattered now.
You've named a whole host of counties there who literally no one has as AI contenders. Galway have been inconsistent within games never mind within seasons since 2017. The fact Galway have usually been really good against TIpp actually backs up his point perfectly.
For what its worth, Galway are contenders in my opinion and they also can lose the next two and still be two wins from an All Ireland final place"
Inconsistent since 2017.

The year after in 2018 unbeaten all championship bar losing an All Ireland Final.

Inconsistent at its best.

You wouldn't believe it unless you read it..........

SamandLiamSoon (Galway) - Posts: 589 - 22/05/2023 15:01:50    2480560

Link

Replying To tiobraid:  "I was expecting this might irk one or two! I'm not his biggest fan but hes just giving an opinion and you're points dont really show anything to say hes wrong. This is the sixth season since Galway won the All Ireland. I'd be laughed out of the place If I suggested anything Tipp done in 2019 mattered now.
You've named a whole host of counties there who literally no one has as AI contenders. Galway have been inconsistent within games never mind within seasons since 2017. The fact Galway have usually been really good against TIpp actually backs up his point perfectly.
For what its worth, Galway are contenders in my opinion and they also can lose the next two and still be two wins from an All Ireland final place"
I think Clare, Cork and even Waterford would definitely regard themselves as "AI contenders"!

tommy k (Galway) - Posts: 3320 - 22/05/2023 17:23:28    2480635

Link

Replying To SamandLiamSoon:  "Inconsistent since 2017.

The year after in 2018 unbeaten all championship bar losing an All Ireland Final.

Inconsistent at its best.

You wouldn't believe it unless you read it.........."
Yes in 2018 Galway had to win at least 7 or 8 matches including 2 replays against KK and Clare to even reach a final where they were tired or "energyless" as Mullane said recently about Clare v KK last year but still only lost by a point in the end and if JC had nailed that last free I would have really fancied our chances in the replay. Amazing how inconsistent they were! Its a bit of a tired cliché that these "pundits" roll out every year and I have heard the likes of Daly and Cummins (both Munster men of course!) come out with the same auld drivel many times over the years.

tommy k (Galway) - Posts: 3320 - 22/05/2023 17:36:02    2480640

Link

Replying To tiobraid:  "I was expecting this might irk one or two! I'm not his biggest fan but hes just giving an opinion and you're points dont really show anything to say hes wrong. This is the sixth season since Galway won the All Ireland. I'd be laughed out of the place If I suggested anything Tipp done in 2019 mattered now.
You've named a whole host of counties there who literally no one has as AI contenders. Galway have been inconsistent within games never mind within seasons since 2017. The fact Galway have usually been really good against TIpp actually backs up his point perfectly.
For what its worth, Galway are contenders in my opinion and they also can lose the next two and still be two wins from an All Ireland final place"
Galway pushed Limerick far closer than any Munster team except Clare last year. And I think are better this year tbh. Sheedy is a great motivator and man manager but not a great pundit.

Viking66 (Wexford) - Posts: 11815 - 22/05/2023 17:46:07    2480647

Link

Replying To tommy k:  "Yes in 2018 Galway had to win at least 7 or 8 matches including 2 replays against KK and Clare to even reach a final where they were tired or "energyless" as Mullane said recently about Clare v KK last year but still only lost by a point in the end and if JC had nailed that last free I would have really fancied our chances in the replay. Amazing how inconsistent they were! Its a bit of a tired cliché that these "pundits" roll out every year and I have heard the likes of Daly and Cummins (both Munster men of course!) come out with the same auld drivel many times over the years."
That Galway are inconsistent thing is a very old lazy comment belong to a previous generation. Galway since 2015
2015-Runners up
2016-1 point semi final loss to Tipp who hammered everyone
2017-Won All Ireland
2018-Runners up
2019-Group stage, madness set of results
2020-2 point loss to Limerick who hammered everyone
2021-disaster year and worst since 2011
2022-2 point All Ireland semi final loss to Limerick
That seems like a fairly consistent 8 years where they didnt make at least semi finals only twice. I think the biggest thing is not getting over the line v Limerick and Kilkenny in last couple Leinster finals but that's a completely different complaint to saying they're inconsistent
Outside of Limerick since 2015 they've played Munster teams 11 times, drew 1 and won 8 and lost just twice, thyve a worse record v Dublin than the rest of Munster outsid if Limerick...that's a fair record. Even throw in the 3 losses to Limerick, it reads played 14, drew 1, won 8, lost 5.
Their biggest loss in those eight years was an 7 point loss to Kilkenny in 2016. Nobody ever hammers Galway, they really earn their win even if theyre going poor. Bar Limerick or Kilkenny, I don't think anyone has same level of consistency over that time period, even Tipp who have 2 all Ireland's in that time period have been very up and down too.

Throughthemidfieldhewasstormin (Wexford) - Posts: 258 - 22/05/2023 18:06:03    2480654

Link