Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

National Forum

Mayo GAA Thread

(Oldest Posts First) - Go To The Latest Post

Replying To otgarom:  "Also Mayo went man to man, you need top quality defenders to do that, its why no other county does it."
The idea that "no other county does it" or that you need "top quality defenders" to survive man-to-man is largely a myth. While Mayo's high-octane pressing approach under Andy Moran stood out, since the new rules introduced in 2025 actually forced every county to abandon pure blanket defenses

Gaa_lover (USA) - Posts: 4122 - 17/11/2026 19:22:55    2700632

Link

Replying To Gaa_lover:  "The idea that "no other county does it" or that you need "top quality defenders" to survive man-to-man is largely a myth. While Mayo's high-octane pressing approach under Andy Moran stood out, since the new rules introduced in 2025 actually forced every county to abandon pure blanket defenses"
It forced the abandonment of the en masse blanket defense but if you listen to punditry and commentary throughout the season you can see that Mayo were the only top level team to not have a zonal element when defending 11v11 and to survive playing that game you need good defenders

otgarom (Mayo) - Posts: 45 - 17/11/2026 20:23:06    2700634

Link

Replying To Drax_the_destroyer:  "Key word is "Active" most commonly means engaged in action and none of Castlebar starting defenders played much of active role other than Durcan off the bench for Mayo in winning that All-Ireland on the field. Won't count McHugh as will be ruled out through injury and his absence makes Castlebar defence significantly weaker.


What I've seen of Tuohy I'd disagree on your view on matching him up with Maher who are regularly curbed some of the most athletic footballers out of games.

Not that bold of statement if you watched the Salthill half line action closely against Brigids Moycullen and Corofin three strong teams and I might add two of them are starting All-Ireland winners."
Active means not retired, being clear that it's not like they're some 40yos who won an All Ireland 15 years ago and are hanging on while not being the player they once were. I would be absolutely shocked if Maher could keep with Tuohy athletically, he's be MOTM the last two days, lording midfield and kicking 11 points from play, aerially he wont be able to match Tuohy either.

otgarom (Mayo) - Posts: 45 - 17/11/2026 20:27:31    2700635

Link

You need good tacklers and the tacking starts in the full forward line and that's where Mayo have been superior. I don't subscribe to the nation our defenders are brilliant.

There isn't a better tackler in the game at this moment in time than Ryan O Donoughue. You need everyone working on the same page for this system to work because a weak link in the chain and it falls apart.

I reckon more teams will improve in their tackling as time moves on. What worked for us this year won't work next year. It's about evolution and Andy suggested this in an interview recently which I was glad to hear.

yew_tree (Mayo) - Posts: 12325 - 17/11/2026 20:51:38    2700636

Link

Replying To otgarom:  "No one said anything about starters, the question was what other club has 4 (3 fit) active All Ireland winners in their back 6, plus an ex intercounty goalkeeper plus a starting All Ireland winning midfielder.

McHale Park will be extremely windy too, not as much as Salthill but it won' be calm.

Bob Tuohy will be more than a match for Maher, he's more athletic, has a better engine and Maher won't outfield him.

Bold claim that Salthills HB is as good as any when it won' even be the best on display in the Connacht Final."
I think it'll be a good competitive game. Hard to call a winner. Different situation for Salthill now as favourites, but they're a very difficult team to beat and have plenty quality.
Just on the comparison, Maher is a freak athletically in terms of his stamina. Physically very strong too, but has incredible endurance. A former cross country runner when he was younger. He'd have the best engine of any player in the Galway team in my opinion.
Fair play to Tuohy, if he's better in that regard. There aren't too many intercounty midfielders who are.

WanPintWin (Galway) - Posts: 3178 - 17/11/2026 20:52:56    2700637

Link

"if you listen to punditry and commentary throughout the season"

Anyone listening to them would be convinced Mayo was going to lose against Meath,Cork and Kerry.

Gaa_lover (USA) - Posts: 4122 - 17/11/2026 21:27:04    2700641

Link

Replying To WanPintWin:  "I think it'll be a good competitive game. Hard to call a winner. Different situation for Salthill now as favourites, but they're a very difficult team to beat and have plenty quality.
Just on the comparison, Maher is a freak athletically in terms of his stamina. Physically very strong too, but has incredible endurance. A former cross country runner when he was younger. He'd have the best engine of any player in the Galway team in my opinion.
Fair play to Tuohy, if he's better in that regard. There aren't too many intercounty midfielders who are."
Tuohy is a young lad and not near Mather's strength yet in my opinion but he can get there eventually. Tuohy was lucky to stay on the field in the all Ireland final. His performances for Mitchell's since have been impressive so it will be very interesting to see how he gets on.

yew_tree (Mayo) - Posts: 12325 - 18/11/2026 07:46:25    2700651

Link

Replying To WanPintWin:  "I think it'll be a good competitive game. Hard to call a winner. Different situation for Salthill now as favourites, but they're a very difficult team to beat and have plenty quality.
Just on the comparison, Maher is a freak athletically in terms of his stamina. Physically very strong too, but has incredible endurance. A former cross country runner when he was younger. He'd have the best engine of any player in the Galway team in my opinion.
Fair play to Tuohy, if he's better in that regard. There aren't too many intercounty midfielders who are."
Tuohy was also a cross country runner and all his family come from athletics background. Should be an exciting match up between himself and Maher.

Dmoa95 (UK) - Posts: 31 - 18/11/2026 12:55:12    2700676

Link

Replying To Dmoa95:  "Tuohy was also a cross country runner and all his family come from athletics background. Should be an exciting match up between himself and Maher."
Just because he has a cross country background doesn't mean he's more athletic than Maher. Tuohy has been in great form in recent weeks however so it'll be a good opportunity to test himself.

MayoDan (Mayo) - Posts: 592 - 18/11/2026 14:44:36    2700689

Link