National Forum

Roscommon GAA thread

(Oldest Posts First) - Go To The Latest Post


All well and good and many saying we could have won it but how did we not deny them space on their kick out second half out on the terrace side especially. Even after the Carey two point which was well worked and executed we totally turned off for the Tyrone kick out and gave them a free play for their last point. There in are the margins at the top level. Was any one not clued in on or off field? And improbably going to get lambasted for this piece of criticism!

moros (Roscommon) - Posts: 1413 - 24/05/2026 19:48:50    2675133

Link

Replying To Towny10:  "And that's why you don't change a winning team endgame. You got your wish."
He and anyone else calling for change got their answer no doubt.

Two changes that ended up being 4 or 5 positional switches that left Roscommon needed the whole 1st half to adjust. Defensively was the biggest issue 1st half as promising whereby issues started with forward moves breaking down from unforced errors and Tyrone scoring on the turnovers. The two pointer right before half time with Roscommom on the attack cheaply losing possession proved costly in a one point defeat.

2nd half Roscommon much better Defensively and if hadcwon it would be thanks to that but that was an awful gift of a goal to Tyrone when the score was 2-15 to 2-13. It was the break Tyrone needed and used all their experience to hang on for a one point win after that.

Roscommon still weren't never their best today and I suppose it shows how much they have improved as in the past Roscommon not at their best would lose by a far bigger margin to Tyrone

Gaa_lover (USA) - Posts: 3968 - 24/05/2026 19:51:15    2675135

Link

Replying To Jack L:  "A Kerry Vs Roscommon Round 2A match would be mouth watering. A chance ho revenge thr controversial 1 point defeat in Killarnry St the end of January"
Round 2B

Seanfan (Roscommon) - Posts: 578 - 24/05/2026 20:54:32    2675159

Link

Replying To Rozzies:  "Presume the losers of Dublin v Louth, Monaghan v Mayo and Kildare are all possible opponents also?"
Yes you're right. I think we can get Mayo if they lose because we didn't meet them in a provincial final. The format changes so often it's hard to keep up.

endgame (Roscommon) - Posts: 2671 - 24/05/2026 21:03:45    2675161

Link

Tyrone were the sharper team tiday they were more assured on the ball. Roscommon played ok and kept in touch but were chasing the game. The two pointer conceeded before half time was a crucial acore. Roscommon dug deep and edged in front after endas goal and diarmuids score. Carrolls kick out was unfortunate there was a roscommon defender wide open in the centre and carroll didnt see him quickly enough a few shouts went to carroll and he rushed his kick and the goal came. Has to be said conor carroll made a few top class saves and was just unfortunate with his timing. Morgan hit 4 or 5 kicks outs late on to the exact same place on the right sideline. I think it was kilpatrick caught it not sure what roscommon pkayer was nearest but it wasnt a midfielder. It should have been picked up on that the same kick out was their out ball. Great two pointer from paul carey but it happened too early roughly 68.12 i think just giving tyrone the last opportunity. Roscommon have achieved alot this year so its not all doom and gloom hopefully a kinder draw for next round

Charliepace (Donegal) - Posts: 41 - 24/05/2026 21:06:00    2675163

Link

Replying To moros:  "All well and good and many saying we could have won it but how did we not deny them space on their kick out second half out on the terrace side especially. Even after the Carey two point which was well worked and executed we totally turned off for the Tyrone kick out and gave them a free play for their last point. There in are the margins at the top level. Was any one not clued in on or off field? And improbably going to get lambasted for this piece of criticism!"
Thought Tyrone's experience was telling
Also their very strong at 8 and 9
Kilpatrick was massive for them
Fair dues to the lads tho we're not far off stupid mistakes ultimately cost us - frustrating but we're close take that defeat on the chin and move on

rossy15 (Roscommon) - Posts: 682 - 24/05/2026 21:18:29    2675166

Link

Replying To Solo_Run:  "It can be any one of the 7 other 1st Round losers ( except Mayo, if they lose to Monaghan). so...

Kerry
Meath
Kildare
Loser - Westmeath / Cavan
Loser - Armagh / Derry
Loser - Dublin / Louth
Monaghan ( if they lose to Mayo)

I'd say priority 1 - avoid Kerry, priority 2 - home draw"
Bring on Kerry

Michaelbeag (Roscommon) - Posts: 64 - 24/05/2026 21:32:26    2675174

Link

Replying To Gaa_lover:  "He and anyone else calling for change got their answer no doubt.

Two changes that ended up being 4 or 5 positional switches that left Roscommon needed the whole 1st half to adjust. Defensively was the biggest issue 1st half as promising whereby issues started with forward moves breaking down from unforced errors and Tyrone scoring on the turnovers. The two pointer right before half time with Roscommom on the attack cheaply losing possession proved costly in a one point defeat.

2nd half Roscommon much better Defensively and if hadcwon it would be thanks to that but that was an awful gift of a goal to Tyrone when the score was 2-15 to 2-13. It was the break Tyrone needed and used all their experience to hang on for a one point win after that.

Roscommon still weren't never their best today and I suppose it shows how much they have improved as in the past Roscommon not at their best would lose by a far bigger margin to Tyrone"
Does a bigger margin matter or not if it's Clare Kildare cork twice Tyrone now, we struggle with division 2 teams after doing well in the first half of the year if it's staying up or promotion

Like it's not all doom and gloom but we seen this story a million times and need a reaction badly

Our first Connacht treble is a brilliant story but losing two knockout championship games would really put a damper on the year

Shame despite our form and Tyrone's and Dublins we stuggle against our boogie teams as we usually do

Gavlar (Roscommon) - Posts: 19 - 24/05/2026 22:15:58    2675189

Link

Replying To Gavlar:  "Does a bigger margin matter or not if it's Clare Kildare cork twice Tyrone now, we struggle with division 2 teams after doing well in the first half of the year if it's staying up or promotion

Like it's not all doom and gloom but we seen this story a million times and need a reaction badly

Our first Connacht treble is a brilliant story but losing two knockout championship games would really put a damper on the year

Shame despite our form and Tyrone's and Dublins we stuggle against our boogie teams as we usually do"
I'm positive about it. There are so many young players on that Roscommon team. Today was disappointing but it can only develop them and bring them on. Roscommon have made huge strides this year. Tyrone are a strong team and today was always going to be difficult after the highs of the Connacht final. Let's see who we draw and go again in three weeks time.

endgame (Roscommon) - Posts: 2671 - 24/05/2026 22:58:49    2675199

Link

Replying To Gavlar:  "Does a bigger margin matter or not if it's Clare Kildare cork twice Tyrone now, we struggle with division 2 teams after doing well in the first half of the year if it's staying up or promotion

Like it's not all doom and gloom but we seen this story a million times and need a reaction badly

Our first Connacht treble is a brilliant story but losing two knockout championship games would really put a damper on the year

Shame despite our form and Tyrone's and Dublins we stuggle against our boogie teams as we usually do"
It's matters as when it comes to championship football Tyrone are a better more seasoned team with All-Ireland winners in their ranks unlike Cork,Clare and Kildare.

Gaa_lover (USA) - Posts: 3968 - 24/05/2026 23:23:26    2675204

Link

Replying To Michaelbeag:  "Bring on Kerry"
Roscommon can play Mayo. Dublin playing Louth next weekend again

Claretandblue (Westmeath) - Posts: 2646 - 24/05/2026 23:38:48    2675208

Link

Replying To Solo_Run:  "It can be any one of the 7 other 1st Round losers ( except Mayo, if they lose to Monaghan). so...

Kerry
Meath
Kildare
Loser - Westmeath / Cavan
Loser - Armagh / Derry
Loser - Dublin / Louth
Monaghan ( if they lose to Mayo)

I'd say priority 1 - avoid Kerry, priority 2 - home draw"
Mayo if they lose to Monaghan.

Seanfan (Roscommon) - Posts: 578 - 25/05/2026 00:25:11    2675213

Link

Look things didn't go our way yesterday and didn't play that well and could have got something out of the game. The two things that really hurt us yesterday was the bad kick out that Tyrone got their 3rd goal and a very poor turn over by cregg before half time and Tyrone kicked a great two pointer. That was 5 needless points to hand Tyrone. First half our defense was way off it and cut open far to easily. Can't afford another loss now so pressure is on now.

dave1988 (Roscommon) - Posts: 1413 - 25/05/2026 08:55:16    2675234

Link

Replying To Claretandblue:  "Roscommon can play Mayo. Dublin playing Louth next weekend again"
Ya, i think it's only provincial final pairings that can't be repeated. So absolutely, we could get Mayo if they fall to Monaghan

D.Hyde (Roscommon) - Posts: 344 - 25/05/2026 11:53:06    2675314

Link

Replying To dave1988:  "Look things didn't go our way yesterday and didn't play that well and could have got something out of the game. The two things that really hurt us yesterday was the bad kick out that Tyrone got their 3rd goal and a very poor turn over by cregg before half time and Tyrone kicked a great two pointer. That was 5 needless points to hand Tyrone. First half our defense was way off it and cut open far to easily. Can't afford another loss now so pressure is on now."
Worrying too see how easy it was for Tyrone to cut through our defence practically unchallenged to score in first half. Their 2nd goal was as poor defending as your ever likely to see. Cassidy got the ball in front of our dugout on the 45 and just soloed down the line and across in front of goal with out a hand being laid on him. We just didn't perform to the standard we have done up to now and we got punished. I have no doubt the lads will bounce back and be ready to go again in 3 weeks. Maybe the 3 weeks off will be a good thing after all the emotion and talk over the last few weeks.

D.Hyde (Roscommon) - Posts: 344 - 25/05/2026 15:56:50    2675467

Link

Replying To D.Hyde:  "Worrying too see how easy it was for Tyrone to cut through our defence practically unchallenged to score in first half. Their 2nd goal was as poor defending as your ever likely to see. Cassidy got the ball in front of our dugout on the 45 and just soloed down the line and across in front of goal with out a hand being laid on him. We just didn't perform to the standard we have done up to now and we got punished. I have no doubt the lads will bounce back and be ready to go again in 3 weeks. Maybe the 3 weeks off will be a good thing after all the emotion and talk over the last few weeks."
Was similar defending with Galways 2nd goal in the Connnacht final, turnover in midfield and Comer allowed to run in unchallenged. Roscommon have a great ability to score 2 or 3 goals a game but do concede some awful soft ones.

Was two possible penalties Roscommon could have got yesterday it all adds up in a fine margin 1 point contest but overall Roscommon are a improved side compared to last year under Davy Burke when Roscommon was just a side fulfilling the fixture and much easier to beat

Drax_the_destroyer (UK) - Posts: 857 - 25/05/2026 16:14:56    2675485

Link

Replying To Drax_the_destroyer:  "Was similar defending with Galways 2nd goal in the Connnacht final, turnover in midfield and Comer allowed to run in unchallenged. Roscommon have a great ability to score 2 or 3 goals a game but do concede some awful soft ones.

Was two possible penalties Roscommon could have got yesterday it all adds up in a fine margin 1 point contest but overall Roscommon are a improved side compared to last year under Davy Burke when Roscommon was just a side fulfilling the fixture and much easier to beat"
Agree but Comers goal came from a mistake by us in the middle of the field and we ended up in a bit of a scramble defence. Tyrone's goal came when we were in defensive shape and set up and he still waltzed through.

D.Hyde (Roscommon) - Posts: 344 - 25/05/2026 19:28:29    2675540

Link

A day on from a disappointing one point loss. A tough draw as it proved to be for us to get against Tyrone who pushed Armagh all the way to extra time and reached the All-Ireland semi-final last year.

Tyrone with weeks to prepare solely on us and having a point to prove made it as tough as it was. 50/50 game it was always going to be and undone by the finest of margins. I'd agree with what Conor Devaney and Sean McDermott said on today rossie podcast, in the past we would have gone into any game against a top 8 team hoping to be competitive while this year in league and championship ever since round 1 v Kerry we now travel to games expecting to be competitive in those games and whoever we play next even if it's the short straw of Kerry in Killarney we should be competitive once more.

A healthy position to be in with a new manager and so many new or newish players blooded.

The_analyser (Roscommon) - Posts: 4377 - 25/05/2026 20:20:42    2675548

Link

Replying To D.Hyde:  "Worrying too see how easy it was for Tyrone to cut through our defence practically unchallenged to score in first half. Their 2nd goal was as poor defending as your ever likely to see. Cassidy got the ball in front of our dugout on the 45 and just soloed down the line and across in front of goal with out a hand being laid on him. We just didn't perform to the standard we have done up to now and we got punished. I have no doubt the lads will bounce back and be ready to go again in 3 weeks. Maybe the 3 weeks off will be a good thing after all the emotion and talk over the last few weeks."
I don't think Galway or Donegal targeted provincials, this year so time to park it, some serious quality there in Roscommon but it's time to focus on yourselves, plenty winnable matches in the hat for yours. Not many will want to be heading your way, if you come out first.

Expertinall (UK) - Posts: 110 - 25/05/2026 21:07:41    2675560

Link