|
Replying To Seanfan: "Who would be relegated to the TC?
Play offs between the 2B losers?
Ros, Kildare, Cavan and Derry this year" That's about the size of it.
legendzxix (Kerry) - Posts: 9926 - 03/07/2026 18:56:14
2684036
Link
0
|
|
Replying To Whammo86: "I'd think it likely the Provincials wither and die pretty quickly without that All Ireland link.
I don't think the status quo is fantastic for them though really either.
Having the National League completed before them lowers their impact." Yeah, well look that's it. If anyone wants to complain about a suggestion that has provincial finalists entering the All Ireland in Round 3, let them bring a motion for promotion or relegation between the All Ireland championship and Tailteann Cup. Put up or shut up!
Regards lowering the impact though, the 4 finals were big events. I'd see the first 4 weekends of the provincial championships as missing an edge. The 8 finalists and 8 qualifiers entering at the same stage is the reason for that.
legendzxix (Kerry) - Posts: 9926 - 03/07/2026 19:02:36
2684037
Link
0
|
|
Replying To legendzxix: "Hmmm...
Round 1 - The 8 qualifiers.
Round 2A - 4 winners from Round 1
Round 2B - 4 losers from Round 1
Round 3A - 4 provincial winners at home to 4 provincial runners up.
Round 3B - 2 losers from Round 2A versus 2 winners from Round 2B.
Round 4 - 4 losers from Round 3A at home to the 4 qualifiers from Round 2A and Round 3B.
Quarter finals - 4 winners from Round 3A versus 4 winners from Round 4.
Schedule:
Weekend 5 - Connacht and Munster finals.
6 - Ulster final, Leinster final and All Ireland Round 1.
7 - All Ireland Rounds 2A and 2B.
8 - Rounds 3A and 3B.
(Rest weekend)
9 - Round 4
(Rest weekend and also Tailteann semi finals!!)
10 - quarter finals
So that's it...
Provincial finalists going straight to Round 3A, with an opportunity to go direct to the quarter finals. Provincial winners with home advantage.
The 2 qualifiers who win in Round 2A get a bye to Round 4 but cannot rank higher than the provincial finalists from Round 3A who would have home advantage in Round 4.
2A losers and 2B winners (4 teams altogether) would play on 3 consecutive weekends but that's the tougher scenic route after missing out on their finals, losing a second game and availing of a lifeline to get to Round 4.
Round 4 would not clash with the Tailteann semi finals weekend, giving the 4 Tailteann semi finalists their fully deserved day out in the spotlight." That's a good layering to provide reasonable incentive in the Prov SFCs (even if the Author provides a handy Rd 3A berth to his 'own county, in a province of hurlers' :)
Another fair layering:
- Prov SF 16 & Rd 1 AIC 'Other 16'
- Prov F 8 & Rd 2 AIC 16 (SF + Rd 1 losers; latter 3rd chance)
- Prov Champs Playoffs 4 & Rd 3 AIC 20 (F loss + R1&2 wins)
- Rd 4 AIC 12 (2 Prov Champ losers + 10 Rd 3 winners)
- AIC KO QFs (2 unbeaten Prov Champs + 6 Rd 4 winners)
- AIC SFs
- AIC F
- TC KO 10 (Rd 3 losers; '4 low NFL ranked' to Prelim QFs)
omahant (USA) - Posts: 3463 - 04/07/2026 03:52:19
2684086
Link
0
|
|
You could have an All Ireland of 3 groups of 6.
Top 2 in each group go to the 12 team knockout round.
Best 4 group winners to quarterfinals, other 8 teams into last 12.
12 teams qualify for the All Ireland at the end of the Provincials.
8 Provincial champions. Previous season's All Ireland champion, Tailteann Cup champion and 2-4 others from the league as needed.
There are 6 qualifiers spaces.
Week 4 is Ulster and Leinster semifinals
week 5 is the Connacht and Munster finals
Week 6 is Ulster and Leinster finals.
Week 7 can be the All Ireland group stage round 1
Week 8 round 2
Week 9 round 3
Week 10 Break
Week 11 Last 12
Week 12 Quarterfinal
Week 13 Break
Week 14 Semifinals
Week 15 Break
Week 16 All Ireland finals.
There's 2 rounds of qualifiers.
16 teams in round 1 made up of teams eliminated before week 4. That can be played in week 5.
The 8 winners of round 1 play the remaining 4 non qualifiers in week 6 for the remaining 6 places.
Qualifiers don't play in week 7.
Provincial champions and Ulster and Leinster finalists don't play in week 8.
Top seeds are the 4 Provincial champions, All Ireland champion and 1 or 2 others from the league.
2nd seeds are the remaining automatic qualifiers.
3rd seeds are the 6 qualifiers.
Tailteann cup of 14 teams. Everyone plays 1 home and 1 away game, all games played to a winner. Any teams winning both games go straight to the quarterfinals. Any team winning 1 game goes to preliminary quarterfinals, any team losing both games are out.
After the preliminary quarterfinals 7 teams remain to be joined by New York to make up 8.
Why is it better?
Every team gets a home and away game in their championship.
Fewer guaranteed league places makes the Provincials more prominent.
Provincial winners seeded and get the best All Ireland schedule.
Only the 4 best group winners going through to the quarters means that there won't be collusion in the final round of group games, the main drawback of groups of 3. Group winners with 2 wins should be treated favourably to those with a draw or a loss.
Qualifiers reduces some of the gap for teams playing their next game after being knocked out of Provincials.
I think it's more fair for an All Ireland round to be the final determining round for qualifiers rather than the siloed provincial championships.
Teams don't play 3 weeks in a row.
Whammo86 (Antrim) - Posts: 4722 - 04/07/2026 12:53:13
2684123
Link
0
|
|
Replying To Whammo86: "You could have an All Ireland of 3 groups of 6.
Top 2 in each group go to the 12 team knockout round.
Best 4 group winners to quarterfinals, other 8 teams into last 12.
12 teams qualify for the All Ireland at the end of the Provincials.
8 Provincial champions. Previous season's All Ireland champion, Tailteann Cup champion and 2-4 others from the league as needed.
There are 6 qualifiers spaces.
Week 4 is Ulster and Leinster semifinals
week 5 is the Connacht and Munster finals
Week 6 is Ulster and Leinster finals.
Week 7 can be the All Ireland group stage round 1
Week 8 round 2
Week 9 round 3
Week 10 Break
Week 11 Last 12
Week 12 Quarterfinal
Week 13 Break
Week 14 Semifinals
Week 15 Break
Week 16 All Ireland finals.
There's 2 rounds of qualifiers.
16 teams in round 1 made up of teams eliminated before week 4. That can be played in week 5.
The 8 winners of round 1 play the remaining 4 non qualifiers in week 6 for the remaining 6 places.
Qualifiers don't play in week 7.
Provincial champions and Ulster and Leinster finalists don't play in week 8.
Top seeds are the 4 Provincial champions, All Ireland champion and 1 or 2 others from the league.
2nd seeds are the remaining automatic qualifiers.
3rd seeds are the 6 qualifiers.
Tailteann cup of 14 teams. Everyone plays 1 home and 1 away game, all games played to a winner. Any teams winning both games go straight to the quarterfinals. Any team winning 1 game goes to preliminary quarterfinals, any team losing both games are out.
After the preliminary quarterfinals 7 teams remain to be joined by New York to make up 8.
Why is it better?
Every team gets a home and away game in their championship.
Fewer guaranteed league places makes the Provincials more prominent.
Provincial winners seeded and get the best All Ireland schedule.
Only the 4 best group winners going through to the quarters means that there won't be collusion in the final round of group games, the main drawback of groups of 3. Group winners with 2 wins should be treated favourably to those with a draw or a loss.
Qualifiers reduces some of the gap for teams playing their next game after being knocked out of Provincials.
I think it's more fair for an All Ireland round to be the final determining round for qualifiers rather than the siloed provincial championships.
Teams don't play 3 weeks in a row." If you look at this season Louth, Tyrone, Derry, Cavan would have had to qualify after poor division 2s and no Provincial finals. To be honest I'd be alright with that.
Louth v Dublin in the Leinster semifinals would have seen 1 go straight to the group stage with the other into the qualifiers.
They'd be seeded for a round 2 qualifier along with Down and Wexford.
Cavan and Wexford would have actually found themselves in a round 1 qualifier, which again would've been ok.
Whammo86 (Antrim) - Posts: 4722 - 04/07/2026 13:36:37
2684128
Link
0
|
|
At the end of the day again, the current format looks like it'll be in place for the foreseeable. Small tweaks here and there are all that are likely. The low hanging fruit are changes around home advantage. With separating provincial championships from the All Ireland not even remotely on the agenda - provincial winners are likely to get home advantage in Round 2.
legendzxix (Kerry) - Posts: 9926 - 04/07/2026 14:48:24
2684152
Link
0
|
|
Replying To legendzxix: "At the end of the day again, the current format looks like it'll be in place for the foreseeable. Small tweaks here and there are all that are likely. The low hanging fruit are changes around home advantage. With separating provincial championships from the All Ireland not even remotely on the agenda - provincial winners are likely to get home advantage in Round 2." Tweaks only for the foreseeable future I expect.
At the risk if boring ye tweaks I'd want are:-
No perks for losing Provincial Finalists
2B and 3 at neutral venues as they are elimination Round.
If a bigger tweak....teams not making Provincial Finals should have some form of prelims to stop the 5/6 week gap.
Seanfan (Roscommon) - Posts: 720 - 04/07/2026 15:14:29
2684157
Link
0
|
|
Replying To legendzxix: "At the end of the day again, the current format looks like it'll be in place for the foreseeable. Small tweaks here and there are all that are likely. The low hanging fruit are changes around home advantage. With separating provincial championships from the All Ireland not even remotely on the agenda - provincial winners are likely to get home advantage in Round 2." Yeah I agree there will only be tweaks.
The above would improve upon some of the weak bits of the current system.
Whammo86 (Antrim) - Posts: 4722 - 04/07/2026 15:52:26
2684168
Link
0
|
|
The qualifier system from 01 to 17 was fine,shoulda been left alone.
Seniorleague (Galway) - Posts: 110 - 04/07/2026 21:42:24
2684242
Link
0
|
|
Replying To Seniorleague: "The qualifier system from 01 to 17 was fine,shoulda been left alone." Aye, wasn't much wrong with it either. Couldn't use that system now as there are too many games and GAA has shortened the season in favour of concerts.
Saynothing (Tyrone) - Posts: 2845 - 04/07/2026 22:18:44
2684248
Link
1
|