National Forum

'The People's Game'

(Oldest Posts First) - Go To The Latest Post


Replying To dahayeser:  "
Replying To DonaldDuck:  "I think AIL attendances sum up the position of rugby in Ireland.

And Pro14 is a mickey mouse compeition anyway
witnof (Dublin) - Posts: 1215 - 21/05/2018 10:40:03
neither of these statements are any bit true.
Some AIL attendances are poor but its an all country league. junior 1/2 competitions with more local teams can get much better attendances
and care to explain how the pro14 is a mickey mouse competition and what is a mickey mouse competition anyway?"
I wouldn't take the AIL attendances as an indicator of much, Rugby is far healthier and more popular than when the AIL was flying 20/25 years ago.

I'd have to agree the Pro14 is a bit of a mess though. You have Glasgow coming over to play Munster missing 25 because of injuries and the 6 nations. Irish teams are restricted from playing half the games for the thing is more often than not played out with half second string players. It's handy to try players out for the big competition , the Champions Cup.

It's similar enough to our own GAA leagues in ways, big teams use it to try out players for championship and if they happen to be there abouts at the end they will give a push to win it. No team is going to show their hand too much in the league if they are meeting the same team in the championship (or Champions cup in Rugby) shortly after.

Typical of the 2 sports then, Rugby people try to big up the Pro14 while GAA people run down their league - ah sure tis only the league!!

In spite of this the GAA leagues are growing massively in popularity with attendances rising massively in recent years."
It is a mess for the reasons you say, not close to full strength teams which means standards are lower, not great attendances. But there can be some good open games as there's less pressure to perform. In that sense it's, as Witnof says, a Mickey Mouse tournament as it's not taken as seriously as Champions Cup. But, no more than some other sports when it's a big competition with more at stake there are boring games where teams are fearful of losing rather than go out to win.

GreenandRed (Mayo) - Posts: 4489 - 22/05/2018 12:27:27    2102986

Link

I wouldn't take the AIL attendances as an indicator of much, Rugby is far healthier and more popular than when the AIL was flying 20/25 years ago.

I'd have to agree the Pro14 is a bit of a mess though. You have Glasgow coming over to play Munster missing 25 because of injuries and the 6 nations. Irish teams are restricted from playing half the games for the thing is more often than not played out with half second string players. It's handy to try players out for the big competition , the Champions Cup.

It's similar enough to our own GAA leagues in ways, big teams use it to try out players for championship and if they happen to be there abouts at the end they will give a push to win it. No team is going to show their hand too much in the league if they are meeting the same team in the championship (or Champions cup in Rugby) shortly after.

Typical of the 2 sports then, Rugby people try to big up the Pro14 while GAA people run down their league - ah sure tis only the league!!

In spite of this the GAA leagues are growing massively in popularity with attendances rising massively in recent years.
dahayeser (Cork) - Posts: 259 - 22/05/2018 10:18:26
Rugby has evolved immensely since AIL was in its hey day and it was in its heyday even 15 years ago
I wouldnt call the pro14 a bit of a mess and its far from just handy for trying out players for the champions cup. Some irish players dont play all the time but thats simply basic squad rotation and to help players have longer careers. Quite different to the GAA leagues considering the pro14 and champions cup are played at same time which isnt case in GAA. Teams very much can and do show their hand in pro14...

DonaldDuck (Tipperary) - Posts: 24 - 22/05/2018 13:49:41    2103011

Link

Replying To galwayford:  "The GAA should try and reach out a bit more to the diaspora who arrive through Dublin airport especially. I always see big adverts for the European rugby games in the arrivals hall. Surely GAA people could try and hire some space for GAA publicity. Also I have said it time and time again, GAA clubs should try and encourage the use of An Gaeilge more. And also maybe Irish dancing. Become "Gaelic hubs" in other words. How about an Irish dancing championship in Croke park? Or a Gaelic only zone? Cén fáth nach bhfuil aon gaeilge ins a lán de na clubanna Gaeil.
Don't let the GAA end up in the ludicrous situation where the local Rugby club is regarded as being the place to go for the culture and craic! It has happened with the anthem, it is said ( silly imho) that the Rugby crowd are more respectful to Amhrán na bhFiann then the GAA."
You have some valid points. I love rugby myself, but grew up playing and loving Gaelic football predominantly. I have posted before about the amount of kids now turning up at longford rugby club, compared to years ago. My nephew is Jonny Sexton mad, and wants every different leinster and Ireland top for his birthdays and Christmas. This is because most of his buddies are the same. Leinster are continually promoting the game of rugby. There will be Rugby summer camps down here along with leinster pre season rugby training. I more or less have to drag him to longford and meath tomorrow.

A couple of weeks ago, I saw something, that 25 yrs ago would never have happened. St mels college here in Longford, was/is an esteemed Gaelic football college. Numerous leinster senior A titles along with 7 or 8 All Ireland's. I can't recall the last time that Mels won the leinster title, maybe early noughties. I think their last All Ireland was 1987.

I now learned that mels, have a very progressive rugby structure in place and this year, subsequently won the development colleges competition. I see another school from longford moyne also contested the plate competition final. For a time yrs ago moyne were competitive with mels in the colleges gaa. Both are now rapidly progressing in the game of rugby.

As I said I love rugby and leinster are to be commended, for the work and promotion they are doing. Unlike their GAA equivalent, they are not forgetting about counties like my own, that are outside the top 5 or 6, and know there is talent to be sourced in every county in the province, including outside the m50.

The gaa have been warned, and if they don't act, they deserve what they get. They can have their super 8's to generate capital for the organization. Super 8's isn't much addition to a lot of so called weaker counties., In 20 yrs it could be a super 4 or a super 2.

Up Longford!!......a win by 2 pts tomorrow (v meath)......and please god my nephew will want a blue and gold Jersey!!!!!!!

Longfordbaz (Longford) - Posts: 79 - 26/05/2018 11:24:47    2103943

Link

Unfortunately the more I follow GAA year after year the more I become convinced it is almost like FIFA in its corruption, collusion and wanting the big names to succeed. Where the strong get stronger and the weak get weaker

The people's game ... it is still that undoubtedly at club level within counties. But at inter-county level it is tiring into an elitist select few who the GAA and the TV stations want to succeed and who get the big money and forget the rest.

Take my own county Leitrim- we played just 4 Division 4 league games. Our games against london and Waterford called off because of weather and deemed not necessary to play by GAA cos none of us could be promoted. Now it's meant to be the people's game !! where all treated equally! Us and Waterford and london (i also believe limerick footballers had a div 4 game called off) told basically we don't matter football wise. Would Dublin or tyrone or Galway or Kerry or mayo or any div 1 or 2 league games be scrapped??? Yet we were . It is an outrage

GAA nepotism for div 1 and 2 family members

Like that famous novel , Animal Farm, said-....

...On this farm all animals are equal ....... it's just some are more equal than others

leitrim4sam (Leitrim) - Posts: 360 - 27/05/2018 00:38:06    2104055

Link

Replying To leitrim4sam:  "Unfortunately the more I follow GAA year after year the more I become convinced it is almost like FIFA in its corruption, collusion and wanting the big names to succeed. Where the strong get stronger and the weak get weaker

The people's game ... it is still that undoubtedly at club level within counties. But at inter-county level it is tiring into an elitist select few who the GAA and the TV stations want to succeed and who get the big money and forget the rest.

Take my own county Leitrim- we played just 4 Division 4 league games. Our games against london and Waterford called off because of weather and deemed not necessary to play by GAA cos none of us could be promoted. Now it's meant to be the people's game !! where all treated equally! Us and Waterford and london (i also believe limerick footballers had a div 4 game called off) told basically we don't matter football wise. Would Dublin or tyrone or Galway or Kerry or mayo or any div 1 or 2 league games be scrapped??? Yet we were . It is an outrage

GAA nepotism for div 1 and 2 family members

Like that famous novel , Animal Farm, said-....

...On this farm all animals are equal ....... it's just some are more equal than others"
I think you are losing the run of yourself - somewhere in there you have some valid points re postponement of games etc. But the reality is this, not a lot want to hear or read it, but when you pit a county with 55,000 people against counties with multiples of that - not even Animal farm could do justice to the gulf in potential, The reality is everyone is unequal at Inter-county level in Football it can't be any other way.

arock (Dublin) - Posts: 3592 - 27/05/2018 19:02:00    2104243

Link

Replying To Longfordbaz:  "You have some valid points. I love rugby myself, but grew up playing and loving Gaelic football predominantly. I have posted before about the amount of kids now turning up at longford rugby club, compared to years ago. My nephew is Jonny Sexton mad, and wants every different leinster and Ireland top for his birthdays and Christmas. This is because most of his buddies are the same. Leinster are continually promoting the game of rugby. There will be Rugby summer camps down here along with leinster pre season rugby training. I more or less have to drag him to longford and meath tomorrow.

A couple of weeks ago, I saw something, that 25 yrs ago would never have happened. St mels college here in Longford, was/is an esteemed Gaelic football college. Numerous leinster senior A titles along with 7 or 8 All Ireland's. I can't recall the last time that Mels won the leinster title, maybe early noughties. I think their last All Ireland was 1987.

I now learned that mels, have a very progressive rugby structure in place and this year, subsequently won the development colleges competition. I see another school from longford moyne also contested the plate competition final. For a time yrs ago moyne were competitive with mels in the colleges gaa. Both are now rapidly progressing in the game of rugby.

As I said I love rugby and leinster are to be commended, for the work and promotion they are doing. Unlike their GAA equivalent, they are not forgetting about counties like my own, that are outside the top 5 or 6, and know there is talent to be sourced in every county in the province, including outside the m50.

The gaa have been warned, and if they don't act, they deserve what they get. They can have their super 8's to generate capital for the organization. Super 8's isn't much addition to a lot of so called weaker counties., In 20 yrs it could be a super 4 or a super 2.

Up Longford!!......a win by 2 pts tomorrow (v meath)......and please god my nephew will want a blue and gold Jersey!!!!!!!"
great win for Longford.

galwayford (Galway) - Posts: 1179 - 27/05/2018 19:20:36    2104261

Link

Replying To galwayford:  "great win for Longford."
Very proud of the team Galwayford. I lived in meath, so little bit sweeter. Great work being done at underage, but at senior level, the lack of playing population comes to the fore a bit.

I suppose nobody outside of longford wouldve saw it coming, but we think they're a talented bunch. Thought they were the best team today and probably should've had a couple of goals, which could be costly down the line.

Belief in themselves is the key now, no matter what happens against the dubs. Pity it's not even at a neutral venue, but we'll go and give it a lash!!

Longfordbaz (Longford) - Posts: 79 - 27/05/2018 19:38:57    2104273

Link